Two comment-only corrections from the final review round.
The `isCompactCheckpoint` redundancy note appealed to the mandatory-marker
invariant to explain something the enclosing branch now states outright:
after e029ffb88 both call sites are literally inside an
`isReplacementSurfaceEvent` branch, so the appeal became retained
reasoning. Say the call sites test it directly.
`appendPreCompactionLog` implied its tool-result content is what survives
compaction, but `bash`'s presenter is static, so the string never reaches
a fixture — the fixtures pin that the shadowed step's card survives.
Neutral text plus a note on where the card body comes from, so a later
reader does not "fix" a fixture to make the sentence true. Verified by the
absence of fixture drift from changing the string.
The replay loop spelled the classification as
`isSurfaceEligibleType(event.type) && !isAppendSurfaceEvent(event)` while
the live listener used `isReplacementSurfaceEvent(event)`. Under the
mandatory-marker invariant these select the same set: the only divergence
is a surface-eligible event carrying no marker, which no active Session
can hold — `Session.append` and the seed construction loop both reject it
through the same `planSurfaceEvent`.
Using the same predicate on both paths makes "both paths classify a
surface event by the same marker" structural rather than argued, and
retires the TUI's last `isSurfaceEligibleType` use.
No behavior change: the TUI suite and all 113 snapshot fixtures pass
unchanged.
Review follow-ups on b9b2e593f, all documentation precision.
The redundancy note on `isCompactCheckpoint` leaned on a reading its call
site does not state: `index.ts` reaches it for surface-eligible non-append
events, which is the same set as replacements only because the marker is
mandatory. Say that instead.
The Agent Note now owns three facts it was leaving to a future reader.
`rebuildTranscript` materializes a component per append-origin event and
runs on mount, color-scheme change, and every reasoning toggle — work
compaction used to bound for exactly the long sessions it serves, so the
cost now tracks session length rather than the surface. `Consequences`
names `surface-replayed-compaction` as the durable evidence for the
live/replay equivalence claim, so the two fixtures that must move together
are findable from the Note rather than the PR thread. `Deferred` records
that a page can now carry a checkpoint whose `surfaceOp.start` fell out of
the window: pagination no longer cuts on the checkpoint's provenance
group, `FoldAdapter` pads with a non-surface sentinel, and `nodes()`
degrades to `degradedSeqs()` — which is already close to the transcript
projection A2 should build deliberately.
Also corrects the definite-assignment comment in the snapshot scenario:
the assertion rests on the awaited setup invoking `beforeMount`, not on
that call being synchronous.
Review follow-ups on the append-origin transcript projection.
The live/replay equivalence claim was stated unconditionally but does not
cover `tool/call`: only replay re-derives call pairing, because a call
event carries no `surfaceOp` of its own and inherits transcript
membership from the `assistant/message` that advertised it — which the
live listener has necessarily just rendered. Narrow the claim in the TUI
README and Agent Note, and record at `rebuildTranscript` why the filter
is replay-only rather than a missing live branch.
Add `surface-replayed-compaction`: the three existing fixtures all come
from the live path, leaving the resume case the bug report leads with
pinned only by a unit test. The new checkpoint mounts with the
replacement already stored and records byte-identical to
`surface-after-compaction-wide`, so the two fixtures now pin the
equivalence they assert. The shared fixture appends move into
`appendPreCompactionLog` / `appendCompactionCheckpoint`.
`MESSAGE_TYPES` is not "human message event types" — it includes
`assistant/message`. Say what the code distinguishes (append-origin
conversation messages vs. model-only replacement copies) at the const,
the `paginate` and `session.history` JSDoc, the apiproxy README, and the
Agent Note.
Also: spell the replace shape as `Extract<SurfaceOp, { op: 'replace' }>`
for symmetry with the module's two other uses; document why
`isCompactCheckpoint` keeps a replacement check that is redundant at both
call sites; say that Ctrl+R toggles reasoning, which rebuilds the
transcript; and qualify "the sole source of derived history" as derived
*model* history now that the transcript is the other projection.
The terminal and history pagination both treated the model-visible surface as
the human transcript. A landed compaction replacement therefore erased the
conversation it summarized — messages the reader had already seen — and a
model-only replacement copy consumed a page's `maxMessages` quota, which could
also split a compaction's provenance from the replacement citing it.
`dsh-session` now exports the marker split `isAppendSurfaceEvent` /
`isReplacementSurfaceEvent`. The terminal replays append-origin surface events,
keeps a shadowed step's tool cards paired through its append-origin assistant
message, and renders one dim marker where a compaction landed; the checkpoint is
recognized through the compaction seam's `isCompactCheckpointSource` contract,
not the shape of the replacement. `session.history` counts only append-origin
human messages. Everything model-facing keeps reading `session.surface`.
Lint: eslint --fix over the merge-crossed projection/command files (arrow
parens, trailing commas, unnecessary assertions), Extract<> replaces the
keyof-map & string intersections no-redundant-type-constituents rejects,
the fold-adapter's merge loop drops its non-null assertions for a
bounds-carrying cursor, one JSDoc line wrapped under max-len (api-catalog
regenerated). Snapshots: the four TUI goldens re-recorded for the merged
event-count shift (the durable command lifecycle adds one event to the
seeded diagnostics log). The headless advanced-toolchain snapshot passes
on CI and fails locally in this sandbox both with and without these
changes (30s child timeout — environment-bound, tracked in the ledger).
CommandService.execute now returns a CommandExecution — the normalized
result plus the commandId minted for its command/run/command/done records —
and the wire admission value carries commandId exactly when matched, so the
issuing client can correlate its RPC acknowledgment with the flow node the
lifecycle events produce. apiproxy api/schema/handler, the connection
fixture, and the TUI/plan/goal consumers follow the new shape.
CommandService.execute appends the log-only pair around every resolved
handler — run before invocation, done at settlement, including thrown and
aborted handlers (kind:'error'); admission misses log nothing. commandId is
minted monotonically per instance; per-session appends serialize through a
tail queue over SessionStore.appendOutOfBand (zero-step wrap on an idle log,
direct join inside an open turn). The invariant companion now asserts the
pairing relation (unique run ids; a done requires a prior in-log run).
CommandSource is a minimal merge-extensible map (user variant only).
Dependent benches mount SessionStore; TUI/e2e snapshots re-recorded for the
executor's durable-append timing and the /status event counts.
Extract model-command, questions, and resume sub-machines from the
~1600-line createTuiChat closure into src/chat/ factories that take
explicit dependency bundles (shared ChatChannelDeps/ChannelNotice).
Reorganize src/ so chat/ holds all chat-channel concerns (former input
and session/ files move under it); xml-tool-output moves to components/;
TuiRuntime/TuiResumeHost move to runtime.ts. index.ts drops 2067->~1530
lines. Behavior identical: 167 tests and all TUI snapshots pass unchanged.
The running status glyph clipped its cosine throb to a blank column below
STATUS_FADE_MIN_OPACITY, so each breath read as bold->dim->disappear rather
than bold->dim->bold. Remove the cutoff and the constant; the trough now
renders as the dimmest gray, giving a symmetric breathe. Turn-boundary
appear/disappear is unchanged (fade envelope and non-truecolor visible
threshold).
Two CI-only test failures on the personal TUI/skills stack:
- packages/ui/tui/tests/tui.spec.ts anchored the dark-palette test at
process.cwd(), which is not guaranteed under $HOME; on CI runners the
prompt rendered an absolute path instead of the `~/` abbreviation. Anchor
cwd under homedir() so the assertion is deterministic.
- examples/tui-agent/tests/tui-keyless-smoke.e2e.ts asserted stale
dsh-customize / dsh-upgrade skill descriptions. Sync the expectations to
the bundled SKILL.md frontmatter.
Consolidates the personal dsh-tui customizations (module split into
components/session/extension, prompt template + running-glyph indicator,
copyable transcript, tool-card headers, timing placement, XML tool output,
status/footer rework) and ports upstream's model reasoning-effort selector
(Shift+Tab effort cycling, effort-aware /model, footer, and /status) onto
the personal module layout.
