The disconnect-mid-prompt test comment said "PR D's per-agent AgentHandle
teardown", narrating the change's origin. Per the repo doc-current-state
convention, state the mechanism (the session's AgentHandle teardown) without
naming the PR that introduced it.
Two blocking lifecycle findings from the deep review:
- `SessionStore.enter()` is a public cross-package primitive that a caller can
separate from `prepare()` by arbitrary work, so it must re-check the id: a
stale prepared session could otherwise overwrite a live store entry of the
same id, and the stale session's detach disposer would later delete the REAL
session. Re-add the duplicate-id throw (removed earlier on a coverage
rationale that only held for the back-to-back internal caller). Tests cover
the stale-overwrite rejection and the prepare/enter/announce lifecycle (which
also covers the throw branch).
- `AgentHandle.dispose()` exposed the raw single-shot cordis effect disposer, so
a concurrent/second dispose() returned immediately (effect epoch already
cleared) instead of awaiting the in-flight teardown — violating the
dispose(): Promise<void> contract that every caller observes the same
quiescence boundary. Memoize the disposal promise in startOwned. Regression
test gates the loop's final flush, fires two dispose() calls, and asserts the
second stays pending until the first's teardown completes (fails without the
memo).
Codex found a real teardown-leak (A): the AgentHandle's composite effect runs
its disposers as a `.then()` chain, and the register disposer emitted
`agent/disposed` UNCONTAINED. A throwing listener rejected the chain, skipping
the LATER session-detach disposer — stranding the session in the store with
`onAppend` attached (a leak AND a durability hole, since the new composite
design relies on detach running). Verified by tracing fiber.ts:299-301
(`task = task.then(dispose)`) against the yield order in AgentLoop.start.
Wrap the disposer's `agent/disposed` emit in try/catch + logger.warn (the
store entry is already removed before the emit — the useful state is captured
— so logging and continuing is correct, mirroring the guarded `agent/status`
emit in ReactLoopAgent). The sibling `agent/created` emit stays uncontained on
purpose: its throw is MEANT to propagate and roll the registration back.
Regression test (acp dispose.spec): register a throwing `agent/disposed`
listener, drive a clean turn, dispose, assert the session was STILL removed.
Confirmed it FAILS without the guard (the throw escapes dispose and detach is
skipped) and passes with it.
Also (B): document the new `prepare`/`enter`/`announce` ordered-teardown
lifecycle primitives in the dsh-session README (they are public cross-package
methods now consumed by dsh-agent-loop).
A stronger durability test (dispose MID-turn, then re-load from disk) caught
that the original two-sibling-effect design dropped the loop's closing
`turn/end` on the bare fiber-dispose path: a fiber unload disposes sibling
effects CONCURRENTLY (`Promise.all`, vendor/cordis/fiber.ts), so the
session-create effect detached `onAppend` racing the loop's final
`session/flush` — the re-loaded log showed crash-recovery's synthetic
`interrupted` closer instead of the real `disposed` reason. The disconnect
path happened to work (only `quiesce()` ran), but the contract must hold
uniformly.
Fix: fold the session lifecycle INTO the agent's single composite effect.
`SessionStore` now exposes `prepare` (validate + construct, no store entry),
`enter` (attach onAppend + store, returns detach), and `announce` (emit
session/created), replacing the sibling-effect `createOwned`. `AgentLoop.start`
builds ONE effect that yields, in order: session-detach, register, then
stop-and-`await agent.done`. LIFO disposal runs them as an ORDERED chain (the
runtime awaits each disposer's promise before the next), so the loop is
stopped and awaited to exit — its closing flush captured through the still-
attached onAppend — BEFORE the session detaches, whether the trigger is the
handle's dispose() OR a fiber unload. The config path uses prepare()+start
too, so it gets the same ordered teardown. All three factory entrypoints now
funnel through the one composite builder.
The mid-turn durability test asserts the REAL `disposed` reason lands on disk
(not a recovered `interrupted` substitute), proving the closing event was
captured rather than reconstructed.
The bridge now holds each session's `AgentHandle` disposer in its
`SessionRecord` and runs it on teardown (client disconnect or fiber dispose)
instead of the old `abort()` + `whenIdle()` drain that left agents
registered. A bare client disconnect now leaves NO registered agent and NO
session-store entry — not an idled-but-still-registered one. The queue-aware
`cancel()` inside the disposer also closes the former pre-step best-effort
window (a turn about to start is dropped), so teardown reaches true
quiescence.
The `session/load`-races-teardown leak is fixed: if the bridge closed while
`resume()` was pending, the just-resumed handle is disposed before throwing,
so it leaves no orphan (it has no SessionRecord, so quiesce() never sees it).
Tests: the disconnect test now asserts (through the SAME memoized teardown)
that the agent is unregistered AND its session removed; a durability test
re-loads the persisted log after dispose and asserts the closing turn/end is
on disk (guards the teardown-order contract); a sibling-isolation test proves
one handle's dispose() leaves other agents untouched. Docs: agent /
agent-loop / acp READMEs, architecture.md, and the stale in-code quiesce()
ownership comment updated to the per-agent disposal model; the now-resolved
TODO(rfc010-agent-disposal) / TODO(rfc010-cancel-prestep) teardown notes
removed.
- AgentLoop.resume uses `this.ctx.get('sessionPersistence')` (strict) instead
of the `, false` overload: still topology-independent, but an inactive/
absent backend reads as undefined (rejected by the existing guard) rather
than being handed back mid-teardown.
- Correct the bridge teardown comment: an ACP-created agent's registry entry
binds to the BRIDGE fiber (the factory is reached through the bridge's
traceable proxy, so AgentLoop.start's `this.ctx.effect` registration uses the
caller context), not the AgentLoop fiber — so an ACP-only HMR dispose
reclaims it. Add a regression test pinning that ownership.
- Sync the ctx.get guidance in the post-mortem, packages/AGENTS.md, and the
dsh-code-review skill to the strict form.
Two independent bugs made the ACP server crash the moment an editor (Zed)
connected, despite 178 green unit tests at 100% coverage:
1. `session/new` threw `cannot get property "agents" without inject`. Root
cause: a stray `export default apply` made the cordis Loader's
`unwrapExports` (`exports.default ?? exports`) collapse the module to the
bare `apply` function, discarding the sibling `inject`/`name`/`Config`
named exports. The plugin fiber was built with empty `inject`, so every
`ctx.<service>` read in `apply` threw at load. Fix: remove the default
export so the Loader uses the namespace.
2. `session/load` threw `cannot get property "sessionPersistence" without
inject`. `AgentLoop.resume` read `this.ctx.sessionPersistence` (a service
it deliberately does NOT inject); the property proxy's ancestor-only fiber
walk fails through the bridge's traceable shadow. Fix: read it via
`this.ctx.get('sessionPersistence', false)`, the topology-independent
global-store lookup.
Why the suite missed both: every test mounted the plugin by hand
(`ctx.plugin({name,inject,apply})`), bypassing `unwrapExports` entirely, and
the only test driving these RPCs was key-gated (skipped in CI). Added a no-key
`session/new` e2e that boots the real example through the real Loader — it
fails loudly on bug #1 without an API key. Set `TSX_TSCONFIG_PATH` in the e2e
spawn so the subprocess resolves workspace `paths` from a temp cwd (it was
silently falling back to a stale built `lib/`).
Docs: post-mortem 0001; AGENTS.md "line coverage is not behavior coverage" +
with-key/smoke-test philosophy; packages/AGENTS.md plugin-export-shape and
ctx.get rules; dsh-code-review SKILL checks.
Implements the RFC 010 MVP: a new `@deepseek-ai/dsh-acp` package bridges the
harness agent to the Agent Client Protocol (JSON-RPC 2.0 over newline-delimited
stdio), so Zed and other ACP editors can drive the coding agent — streaming
render, tool-call display, and resumable sessions via `session/load`.
- packages/acp: AgentSideConnection wiring; initialize/newSession/loadSession/
prompt/cancel; a total TurnEndReason→StopReason codec; settle-once with a
fallback chain (agent/turn-end → logged turn/end → idle); single-session
guard; cwd-must-equal-launch-dir validation; load replays from the persisted
event log (assistant/chunk→agent_message_chunk, tool/call/result→tool_call*).
- agent: add Agent.whenIdle() quiescence signal to the interface; LoopAgent
implements it (resolves on the first running→idle/disposed transition). The
bridge awaits it on disposal so teardown reaches quiescence, not just abort.
- examples: extract the shared provider/tool core into examples/base.yml;
coding-agent nest-includes it; new examples/acp-agent serves the agent over
ACP with JSONL persistence and no stdout logger (stdout is the protocol).
- Permission gate deferred (TODO(rfc010-permission-gate)): tools run with the
executor's full authority; only the Agent→sessionId ownership seam is laid
down. Cancel is best-effort for a not-yet-started queued turn
(TODO(rfc010-cancel-prestep)). RFC 010 stays `proposed`.
- Docs: package README + Zed snippet; client-driver cookbook section; root and
packages layout/commands; RFC 010 implementation-status note.
48 bridge tests + whenIdle coverage; 100% per-file coverage; e2e boots the
example as a subprocess and verifies a written file on disk (key-gated, with a
no-key stdout-purity check).
