Two had real security consequences:
The bootstrap rejection ran on npm dotenv's parser while process.loadEnvFile
applied the file with Node's own. Two independently maintained dialects meant
the check and the thing it guards could disagree: a name Node accepts but the
checker misses would reach process.env unchecked, and BASH_ENV there runs a
file of the project's choosing on every `bash -c` the bash tool issues. Parse
once with node:util's parseEnv — the same engine loadEnvFile uses — and assign
the entries already checked, which also drops the dotenv dependency.
llm-pi-ai still returned a literal profile.apiKey ahead of everything, and it
registers a settings namespace, so the defect removed from llm-deepseek
survived intact in its design twin. The field is gone from the profile schema,
the resolution path, and the tests.
The rest are consistency and documentation defects the review named:
- verify-config-source-ownership did not scan the Python runtime's bundled
cordis.yml, which still inlined apiKey and baseURL. Both are covered now, and
the line-anchored INLINE_DENY documents that it is a tripwire, not a parser.
- The deny list missed NODE_TLS_REJECT_UNAUTHORIZED, the askpass hooks, the
GIT_CONFIG_* redirections, and PYTHONHOME — all implied by its own stated
rule about what a variable does.
- Snapshot lookups folded case on Windows, where environment names are
case-insensitive and an exact-match Map could miss a higher-ranked layer.
- The credentials note claimed a read-time permission check was "not taken"
while this PR implemented it; the credentials-local README still described
two layers, live process.env reads, dotenv-era limitations, and a renamed
anchor; the llm-deepseek README still advertised the removed literal apiKey;
and web.ts and base.cordis.yml kept personal-overlay wording.
- The ownership note's literal-apiKey claim now names its scope: the
web-search providers keep a literal field but register no settings
namespace, so nothing can shadow a stored credential through them.
Master removed the TUI package, the `meta` and `upgrade` subcommands, and
`--config-replace`, and made raw `dsh` require a `--config` overlay. Resolved
onto that shape:
- Dropped this branch's TUI edits with the surface itself, including
`tui.cordis.yml`, `runTui`, and the TUI keyless PTY smoke.
- Dropped the `--config-replace` plumbing rather than reintroducing a flag
master deliberately removed. The gap this branch fixed remains: `dsh -p`
still could not name its composition, so it keeps `--config`.
- Kept this branch's deletion of the personal `$DSH_HOME/config.yaml` layer,
which master still carried, and provided the environment snapshot in the new
raw `runConfig` surface alongside web and headless.
- Ported the headless shutdown PTY test off the personal overlay onto a named
`--config` file, which is what proves that flag now exists on `-p`.
Review found five real defects in the configuration-source work, all confirmed
against the code rather than argued:
1. The note claimed --config outranks settings.yaml. It does not: the settings
seam registers a plugin's cordis entry config as the `base` layer and the
user section layers over it, and the seam cannot tell a shipped value from a
--config one. The note now states shipped reality and names --config-replace
as the lever for a deployment that must win. Separately, a literal `apiKey`
in settings outranked both the environment and .credentials.yaml — the field
is removed, so configuration carries a reference and nothing else.
2. DEEPSEEK_SEARCH_BASE_URL was functionally deleted: the shipped inline went
away without the provider learning to read it. It now resolves from the
environment snapshot, as the README always claimed.
3. The bootstrap deny list missed the interpreter start-up hooks. BASH_ENV is
the sharpest: `bash -c` sources it on every bash tool call, so a project
.env could run a file of its choosing before every command. The list now
covers BASH_ENV and its per-language siblings, the Git hook commands, and
the remaining preload and CA variables, organised by what a variable does
rather than which runtime owns it.
4. YAML parse errors quoted the offending source line — which in a credentials
document is the secret — into boot stderr and the watcher's logger. Only the
error code and position are reported now, in credentials-local and
settings-local alike, pinned by a test that asserts the secret is absent.
5. 0600 governed only files the harness wrote. A hand-created 0644 document was
read normally. POSIX now checks the mode before reading contents, at boot
and on every reload; Windows has no mode to inspect and is skipped rather
than faked.
The project a session is launched in is trusted by default, with no prompt and
no stored trust record: it may supply its own endpoint, ordinary variables, and
a key ranked below the managed store. Trust stops at the harness itself — a
discovered file still cannot set DSH_PERMISSION_MODE, PATH, BASH_ENV, or the
rest, because those take effect with no user action, before any turn, outside
the permission policy and the sandbox.
$DSH_HOME/.env had just become an ordinary environment layer, which left the
harness resolving user-facing values from a flattened process.env that could
no longer say where a value came from. A key stored through the web page
stayed shadowed by an older key in the user's own .env. An endpoint could be
redirected by the project: the invoking directory's .env is materialized like
every other layer, and a base URL decides where a resolved API key is sent, so
a DEEPSEEK_BASE_URL written into a model-editable workspace would send the
user's credential — and the prompts carrying their code — to whatever host
that file named.
Give every user-facing value one ordering, with four kinds of source:
explicit for this run per-operation override, CLI argument
> authored by deployment --config / --config-replace
> this launch's shell inherited process environment
> product-managed store settings.yaml, .credentials.yaml
> discovered file $DSH_HOME/.env
> defaults schema default, shipped base, public default
The domains differ only in which tiers exist. The earlier split — credentials
ranking the environment over the managed file while settings ranked over the
environment — was inconsistent: the distinguishing fact is who authored the
source, not the domain.
packages/util/environment owns an immutable snapshot with per-layer
provenance. getFrom(name, sources) searches only the layers a caller names,
and omitting one is a refusal rather than a demotion: the adapters ask for
['process', 'user-env'], so no reordering can let a project file back into a
decision it was excluded from.
isBootstrapOnly rejects, before anything is materialized, any .env setting a
variable that governs how a process launches (PATH, SHELL, NODE_OPTIONS,
LD_PRELOAD), where code or model-visible instructions load from (the whole
DSH_* namespace, HOME, XDG_*), or how the network is reached (proxy and CA
variables). The namespace is denied wholesale so a switch added later cannot
become settable by being forgotten, and there is no opt-out.
verify-config-source-ownership keeps both rules: no unregistered process.env
read under packages/*/*/src (26 allowlisted with reasons), and no apiKey,
baseURL, or headers inlined from the environment in shipped Cordis config —
removing those inlines is what makes the deployment tier meaningful.
$DSH_HOME/.env carried two incompatible jobs. As credentials-local's writable
secret store it could not be hoisted into process.env — hoisting makes every
stored key read as a read-only launch override and blocks rotation from the
TUI and the web page. But its name and dotenv format promise an environment
file, so a DEEPSEEK_BASE_URL sitting beside a working DEEPSEEK_API_KEY in the
same file was silently ignored: only the credential provider read the
document, and it addresses credential references alone.
Split the two jobs into two files.
.credentials.yaml is the provider-managed store: a strict YAML mapping of
CredentialRef to non-empty string, no version field, no wrapper level. Because
it holds credentials and nothing else, a non-mapping root, a non-identifier
key, a non-string value, an empty string, a duplicate key, and malformed YAML
are all rejections rather than skipped entries — loud at boot and at a write,
warn-and-keep-last-good on a live reload. The dotenv physical-line editor
gives way to a patch of the parsed document, so comments and untouched entries
keep their formatting and any string value round-trips, multi-line included.
Writer lock, read-modify-write, atomic 0600 write under a 0700 directory,
watcher, self-write suppression, and quiescent disposal are unchanged.
$DSH_HOME/.env becomes the user's ordinary environment layer. app-boot's new
loadLayeredEnv loads the invoking directory's .env then the Harness home's,
giving user < project < inherited; the home resolves from the inherited
environment first, so a project .env cannot redirect it.
Credential precedence is unchanged: the live environment still wins read-only
over the file, and shadowed writes still reject. Whether a provider-managed
store should instead win over the environment is a separate decision.
No migration: a key already in $DSH_HOME/.env keeps resolving through the new
environment layer, as a read-only env source that shadows the stored one.
session-title already registers a title projection unit; /resume now
reads it instead of scanning logs: live rows from the registry
snapshot, persisted rows from the durable checkpoint row
(cachedSnapshot, zero I/O), and only rows without a usable checkpoint
pay a coldSnapshot — checkpoint plus readFrom tail, written back so the
next scan is metadata-only. Cold reads are bounded by the new
resumeScanConcurrency config; compositions without the cache fall back
to the bounded readTitleSnapshots batch. The TUI overlay mounts the
projection registry, storage, and projection-cache rows over the same
storages root the web surface uses, so checkpoints serve both.
The review caught the pwshCoverageExclusions comment claiming the inverse of
the code's behavior: a bare-PATH probe FAILING grants the exemption, so a
win32 host where only install-location pwsh (or 5.1) resolves kept the
exemption while its suites ran - over-exempting, never tightening.
resolvePwshPath/candidatePwshPaths move to the dependency-free
pwsh-local/src/resolve.ts (index.ts re-exports; public API unchanged) and
vitest.config.ts probes with that shared definition, so the exemption is
active exactly when the suites skip. The two spec headers stop saying
'on PATH' for a probe that is deliberately not PATH-only, and the parity
note records the abort backport as the one both-ways parity change (both
languages, pairing re-recorded); catalogs regenerated for the line shift.
- fromRequest placeholder: the last two braces of a consecutive } run now
terminate the placeholder, so patterns may end with a brace quantifier
(bot warning; the truncated pattern could even silently mis-match since
an unclosed { is literal in JS regexes)
- document that derived JSONL entries pass through the same resolution
- widen ToolRunContext/deferContext seam docs beyond composite-only usage
(source JSDoc, README pair, core-data-structures type-equiv blocks)
- pin direct-human blocked as uninstructed, completing the
goal-round/direct-human x complete/blocked test quadrant
A goal round reporting complete or blocked used to conclude the turn at
the tool result, so the model never spoke after the call and sessions
ended on a bare update_goal card. The terminal update now defers one
plugin-sourced <goal_complete>/<goal_blocked> instruction onto its
result asking for a grounded closing message without further tool
calls; the turn then ends through the ordinary no-tool-calls stop.
Direct-human mutations stay uninstructed. Wording chosen by A/B
sampling on deepseek-v4-pro; one extra request per goal lifecycle.
New keyless ACP snapshot goal-wrapup drives the shipped app through
create -> round one -> autonomous complete and pins the injection, the
same-turn closing message, and the completed turn end.
Adds the new continuable types to the cordis-catalog type-link map and
regenerates the cordis api/service/event catalogs, tool catalog, config
catalog, and doc graphs.
Implement the continuable background subagents RFC: a durable child
session with a series of Task-backed activations, each disposing its
run before the Task settles.
- dsh-subagent: rename SubagentRun.sendMessage to strict steer, drop
run-level resume, add SubagentProvider.resume dispatch via
SubagentService.resume, the continuation start field, and the
versioned model-hidden subagent/descriptor session event.
- dsh-subagent-inprocess/-spawn/-fork: publish the control-allocated
child id, append the descriptor inside the initial turn, implement
cold resume from the child's own transcript under the live parent
scope, and strict running-only steer.
- dsh-subagent-control (new): SubagentControlService owning stable
child ids, descriptor snapshot/fold/authorization, Task-backed
activation with settle-then-dispose ordering, the process-local
active-run association, and steer-or-resume sendMessage routing.
- dsh-tool-subagent: background route branches on the provider's
resume capability (continuable via the control service; one-shot
task for ACP), returning both child and task ids.
- dsh-tool-subagent-control (new): the globally named send_message
tool rendering steered/started routes.
Keyless coverage spans Task ownership and disposal ordering, running
delivery, cold follow-up, descriptor rejection and rollback, known-id
reconstruction, kill during lookup, admission races, and a new
subagent-continuable ACP snapshot scenario.
ds-review-bot round 1 on the DSH-home integration:
- generated wrappers now inject the services their manifest needs (skills/
tools beside loader), and loadPreparedRepository rejects a wrapper fiber
that settles anything but ACTIVE — a composition missing a required
service fails the repository transaction instead of committing an ACTIVE
row over a silently PENDING child (critical finding)
- the github: source ref segment excludes '#', so 'a#b' refs fail at the
config parser with the promised syntax instead of inside pnpm
- watchPersonalPatches re-reads the include's non-patch options per refresh
instead of a registration-time snapshot
- the TUI smoke's cache-seeded wrapper is produced by the real
prepareDshPlugin (cache LAYOUT stays a deliberate external pin)
- new Loader integration test drives a live repositories update through
entry.update: generation swap, old skills removed, failed candidate
rolled back to the previous generation
ds-review-bot round 1 on the repository-plugin runtime:
- a manifest-declared skill root absent or non-directory in the installed
package now fails the plugin load (skill-local treats a missing root as
legitimately empty, which silently mounted a skill-less plugin)
- includeDefaultRoots: false no longer inherits $DSH_BUNDLED_SKILL_DIR, so
isolated repository providers see only their explicit roots
- prepared wrapper baseUrl schema requires the file: scheme, failing hostile
URLs at the declared validation boundary
- preparedPath reuses format.ts's isOutside; SERVER_NAME_PATTERN is exported
and pinned equal to dsh-mcp-client's, with the restatement justified (the
prepare bin keeps a zod-only module graph); the unexplained `as never`
cast now carries its schemastery rationale
- the import-free wrapper assertion also rejects dynamic import(
- the headless fixture wrapper is regenerated by the real prepareDshPlugin
and a drift test pins fixture == generator output
- prepareDshPlugin JSDoc states the non-atomic publish repair contract
- inline the collect() identity wrapper now that both streams use the
seam's diagnostic-tail shape
- resolve the packaged rg path lazily at the first call (memoized):
@vscode/ripgrep resolves its platform package at module evaluation, so a
static import turned a missing/corrupt platform package into a Loader
composition failure instead of the documented per-call SEARCH_FAILED
- classify synchronous spawn-creation throws (a NUL in argv, an abort
racing the pre-check, a rejected resolution) into SEARCH_FAILED /
SEARCH_ABORTED instead of leaking raw errors
- correct the stderrMaxBytes contract: the stderr excerpt is embedded in
SEARCH_* error messages, not hidden from the model
- export virtualManifest and pin its three acceptance paths (prefix hit,
pnpm-11 truncated-name content-scan fallback, both miss) with fixture
unit tests
Tests: rg-path.spec.ts (resolution failure + memoized rejection),
tools.spec.ts spawn-creation classification, notices spec virtualManifest.
Merges master (default-workspace-write-ui, installer-adopt-checkout,
remove-scoped-bash, goal-clear-single-flight, frontend-plugin-loader,
install-interface-choice, …).
Conflict resolutions:
- apps/cli/tests/shipped-composition.e2e.ts: keep the fixed glob/grep
roster assertion; master's workspace-write composition now confines
tool-bash, so the escalation pair is pinned present (my earlier
absence pin is superseded) together with master's permission facts.
- even-out-shipped-tool-rosters note: both sides edited it; the merged
text keeps both sets of changes and the pair is re-recorded.
- delete the singleQuote shell-quoting helper and its bash-spawning tests
(no in-repo consumers; no shell layer exists anymore)
- drop spill from both collect streams: the tool never reads a raw spill
path, and a lossy stdout read is a pure SEARCH_RAW_OUTPUT_OVERFLOW error
- prepend --no-config so a host RIPGREP_CONFIG_PATH cannot inject a --pre
preprocessor into the unconfined spawn
- promote graceMs and stderrMaxBytes to validated Config fields (defaults
SEARCH_GRACE_MS / SEARCH_STDERR_MAX_BYTES) instead of inheriting
bash-local's config
- correct the grep tool's JSDoc seam reference (bash -> subprocess)
- drop the dead exit-127/command-not-found classification branch
