refactor agent pre-step inbox lifecycle

This commit is contained in:
_Kerman
2026-07-31 19:21:16 +08:00
parent c2ff9ddec8
commit fcc2b5e282
267 changed files with 2052 additions and 1546 deletions

View File

@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write .agents/notes/implemented/simplification/2026-07-17-one-send-one-turn.md
2026-07-17-one-send-one-turn.md: 3ae43f137206f25bdbc563875c17e24211f17d6b
2026-07-17-one-send-one-turn.zh.md: 097090073f44194a8f8d4578a8cc39ffc723eb79
2026-07-17-one-send-one-turn.md: 8f851088d191915cca2637a8962d2368eaa919b2
2026-07-17-one-send-one-turn.zh.md: 6abe748cf505cf4c006a35801575989d972e61ce

View File

@@ -10,21 +10,21 @@ Suppose a caller submits message A and then message B with two `Agent.send()` ca
That grouping depends on timing rather than caller intent. Calls from one synchronous stack, neighboring microtasks, event listeners, and model callbacks could be grouped differently even though every caller used the same API.
This grouping changes behavior, not just the number of model calls. One ordinary turn owns prompt admission, `turn/start`, `turn/end`, and a durability checkpoint. If message B shares message A's turn, B can enter A's model request instead of first seeing A's closed result in the session log. Allowing one message while blocking another also requires a mixed state that no caller requested.
This grouping changes behavior, not just the number of model calls. One ordinary turn owns one claimed follow-up, `turn/start`, `turn/end`, and a durability checkpoint. If message B shares message A's turn, B can enter A's model request instead of first seeing A's closed result in the session log. Entering one follow-up while rejecting another also requires a mixed state that no caller requested.
## Decision
The rule is simple: each successful `send()` creates one independent FIFO queue item. If that item runs, it is the only ordinary message in its turn. An item can be dropped before it starts, so the precise guarantee is at most one turn rather than exactly one; two sends are never silently combined.
Before enqueueing an item, `send()` checks the agent state and accepts an already identified, deeply frozen message. It mints an occurrence-local `InboxItemId` and publishes `agent/inbox/enqueue`; the pending occurrence remains addressable under the [addressable queue operations](../feature/2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.md) decision until the driver claims or discards it.
Before inserting a message, `send()` checks the agent state and accepts an already identified, deeply frozen value. The durable splice and `agent/inbox/inserted { message }` retain its `MessageId`; the pending message remains addressable through `Inbox.update()` and `Inbox.remove()` until the driver claims or discards it. The [claimed pre-step inbox decision](../architecture/2026-07-31-claimed-pre-step-inbox-lifecycle.md) owns the current lifecycle.
If messages A and B are both processed, B's turn starts only after A records `turn/end` and A's durability checkpoint settles. B's request therefore sees whatever closed result A left in the same session log. A checkpoint error is reported, but settlement only releases this ordering barrier; it does not make a failed write durable. Broad `cancel()`, disposal, or a failure before `turn/start` can instead discard an unstarted item without opening an empty turn.
Prompt admission decides one message at a time before a turn opens. An allowed prompt becomes that turn's `user/message`; a blocked prompt is discarded without opening a turn or writing session history. Mixed-batch and all-blocked-batch branches do not exist.
At a turn boundary, the loop claims one follow-up after pending next-step input. `agent/pre-step` either rejects the proposal or returns the complete entering batch. A rejected follow-up remains removed without opening a turn or writing session history. Mixed ordinary follow-up branches do not exist.
The no-batching rule applies only to ordinary `send()`. Running `steer()` puts input in the outbox. While a turn remains open, the loop records that input at the next step boundary and steering makes another step the default. A failure before that boundary leaves the steering staged without waking the agent; a request-error retry action or a later prompt takes it, while cancellation or disposal can discard it. When the agent is idle, `steer()` delegates to `send()`, so it creates an independent ordinary queue item.
The no-batching rule applies only to ordinary follow-up input. `steer()` puts input in the next-step inbox and wakes the driver. During a turn, the loop can claim it at a later step boundary; while idle, the waking next-step batch starts a new turn. Input arriving after a batch was claimed waits for a later boundary, while cancellation or disposal can discard it.
`inject()` continues to add model-facing context without submitting an ordinary message. During a turn it waits in the outbox for a safe step boundary; while idle it appends a `user/message` directly, without opening a turn or running the model. Persistence owns the resulting eager drain. `cancel()` remains a whole-agent operation that can clear all unstarted ordinary and steering input and abort the current step. `status` and `whenIdle()` also describe the whole agent, not one message. Several one-message turns can share one `running` interval, so `running` does not prove that a turn is open.
`inject()` continues to add model-facing context without submitting ordinary input or waking the driver. It always waits in the next-step inbox for a later pre-step, including while idle; AgentLoop records it as `user/message` only when an enter decision returns it inside a turn. `cancel()` remains a whole-agent operation that can clear all unstarted ordinary input, steering, and injection and abort the current step. `status` and `whenIdle()` also describe the whole agent, not one message.
## Alternatives considered
@@ -35,11 +35,11 @@ The no-batching rule applies only to ordinary `send()`. Running `steer()` puts i
- Unit and property tests submit sends from the same stack, neighboring microtasks, different producers, and reentrant callbacks; every message gets its own FIFO-ordered turn.
- A built-stdio test submits two lines and observes two model requests and two turn boundaries.
- Delayed and rejected first-turn checkpoints keep the next turn waiting and prove that its request sees the preceding assistant result.
- Failure-path tests cover prompt veto, listener failure, broad cancellation, disposal, and failure before `turn/start`; rejected admission creates no turn, recorded turns stay balanced, messages do not merge, and surviving queued work still drains.
- Separate tests cover open-turn, failed-turn, and idle `steer()`, plus `inject()`, whole-agent status, and `whenIdle()`.
- Failure-path tests cover pre-step rejection, listener failure, broad cancellation, disposal, and failure before `turn/start`; rejection creates no turn, recorded turns stay balanced, messages do not merge, and surviving later work still drains.
- Separate tests cover open-turn, failed-turn, and idle `steer()`, pending `inject()`, whole-agent status, and `whenIdle()`.
## Consequences
Ordinary turn boundaries are predictable: messages A and B stay separate, and B runs only after A has closed and reached its checkpoint. Callers still do not receive a per-send completion handle; a pending occurrence can be removed through its live `InboxItemId`, broad cancellation can discard the entire unstarted tail, and status and quiescence remain agent-wide observations.
Ordinary turn boundaries are predictable: messages A and B stay separate, and B runs only after A has closed and reached its checkpoint. Callers still do not receive a per-send completion handle; a pending message can be removed through its `MessageId`, broad cancellation can discard the entire unstarted tail, and status and quiescence remain agent-wide observations.
The trade-off is more model requests and more checkpoints. A busy queue can take longer to drain and can grow under sustained producers. Ordinary-send batching returns only through an explicit, measured contract.

View File

@@ -10,21 +10,21 @@ Status: implemented
这种分组取决于运行时机,而不是调用方的意图。因此,即使所有调用方使用相同 API,来自同一个同步调用栈、相邻微任务、事件监听器和模型回调的调用也可能产生不同分组。
这种分组改变的不只是模型调用次数。一个普通轮次包含提示词准入、`turn/start`、`turn/end` 和持久性检查点。如果消息 B 与消息 A 共用轮次,B 可能直接进入 A 的模型请求,而不是先看到 A 在会话日志中已经关闭的结果。若系统允许一条消息、阻止另一条消息,还需要引入调用方没有请求的混合状态。
这种分组改变的不只是模型调用次数。一个普通轮次包含一条已领取 follow-up、`turn/start`、`turn/end` 和持久性检查点。如果消息 B 与消息 A 共用轮次,B 可能直接进入 A 的模型请求,而不是先看到 A 在会话日志中已经关闭的结果。若系统让一条 follow-up 进入、却拒绝另一条,还需要引入调用方没有请求的混合状态。
## 决策
规则很简单:一次成功的 `send()` 创建一个独立的 FIFO 队列项。该队列项如果运行,就是所在轮次中唯一的普通消息。队列项可能在启动前被丢弃,因此精确保证是最多一个轮次,而不是必定一个轮次;两次 send 绝不会被悄悄合并。
队列项入队之前,`send()` 会检查 agent 状态,并接受已有标识且经过深度冻结的消息。它会铸造一个仅属于本次入队的 `InboxItemId`,并发布 `agent/inbox/enqueue`;根据[可寻址队列操作](../feature/2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.md)决策,在驱动器认领或丢弃该项之前,这次待处理入队始终可以被寻址。
消息插入之前,`send()` 会检查 agent 状态,并接受已有标识且经过深度冻结的值。持久 splice 与 `agent/inbox/inserted { message }` 会保留其 `MessageId`;在驱动器领取或丢弃该消息之前,可以通过 `Inbox.update()` 与 `Inbox.remove()` 寻址。当前生命周期由[已领取 pre-step inbox 决策](../architecture/2026-07-31-claimed-pre-step-inbox-lifecycle.md)规定。
如果消息 A、B 都进入处理,B 的轮次只能在 A 记录 `turn/end` 且 A 的持久性检查点处理结束后开始。因此,B 的请求能看到 A 在同一会话日志中留下的已关闭结果。检查点错误会照常报告,但处理结束只表示解除这道顺序屏障,不表示失败的写入已经持久化。广义 `cancel()`、dispose(资源释放)或 `turn/start` 之前的失败也可能丢弃尚未启动的队列项,而不打开一个空轮次。
提示词准入会在轮次打开前,每次只决定一条消息。获准提示词成为该轮次的 `user/message`;被阻止的提示词会被丢弃,不打开轮次,也不写入会话历史。实现中不存在混合批次或全阻止批次分支。
轮次边界上,循环会在待处理 next-step 输入之后领取一条 follow-up。`agent/pre-step` 要么拒绝提案,要么返回进入步骤的完整批次。被拒绝的 follow-up 保持已删除,不打开轮次,也不写入会话历史。实现中不存在混合普通 follow-up 分支。
上述不合批规则只适用于普通 `send()`。agent 运行时,`steer()` 会把输入放入 outbox。只要当前轮次仍然打开,agent loop 就会在下一个步骤边界记录该输入,而 steering(中途引导)会默认让循环再执行一个步骤。在到达该边界前发生失败,会让 steering 保持暂存且不唤醒 agent;请求错误的重试动作或后续提示词会取走它,而取消或 dispose 可以将其丢弃。agent 空闲时,`steer()` 会委托给 `send()`,因此创建一个独立的普通队列项。
上述不合批规则只适用于普通 follow-up 输入。`steer()` 会把输入放入 next-step inbox 并唤醒驱动器。在轮次期间,循环可以在后续步骤边界领取它;agent 空闲时,这个会唤醒的 next-step 批次会启动一个新轮次。批次被领取后才到达的输入会等待后续边界,而取消或 dispose 可以将其丢弃。
`inject()` 继续添加面向模型的上下文,而不提交普通消息。轮次打开时,该上下文会留在 outbox 中,等待安全的步骤边界;agent 空闲时,系统会直接追加一条 `user/message`,既不打开轮次,也不运行模型。持久化层独立负责由此产生的即时排空。`cancel()` 仍是面向整个 agent 的操作,可以清空所有尚未启动的普通输入和 steering,并中止当前步骤。`status` 和 `whenIdle()` 描述的也是整个 agent,而不是某一条消息。多个单消息轮次可以共用一个 `running` 区间,因此 `running` 不表示轮次一定处于打开状态。
`inject()` 继续添加面向模型的上下文,但不提交普通输入,也不唤醒驱动器。即使 agent 空闲,它也始终在 next-step inbox 中等待后续 pre-step;AgentLoop 只会在 enter 决策于轮次内返回它时,将其记录为 `user/message`。`cancel()` 仍是面向整个 agent 的操作,可以清空所有尚未启动的普通输入、steering 和注入,并中止当前步骤。`status` 和 `whenIdle()` 描述的也是整个 agent,而不是某一条消息。
## 曾考虑的替代方案
@@ -35,11 +35,11 @@ Status: implemented
- 单元测试和性质测试从同一调用栈、相邻微任务、不同生产方和重入回调提交 send;每条消息都会得到一个按 FIFO 排序的独立轮次。
- stdio 构建产物测试提交两行输入,并观察到两个模型请求和两个轮次边界。
- 延迟和拒绝第一个轮次的检查点,都能让下一个轮次保持等待,并证明其请求可以看到前一条助手结果。
- 失败路径测试覆盖提示词否决、监听器失败、广义取消、dispose 和 `turn/start` 之前的失败;准入拒绝不会创建轮次,已记录的轮次保持边界平衡,消息不会合并,仍需处理的排队工作也能继续清空。
- 其他测试分别覆盖轮次打开时、轮次失败后和空闲时的 `steer()`,以及 `inject()`、面向整个 agent 的状态和 `whenIdle()`。
- 失败路径测试覆盖 pre-step reject、监听器失败、广义取消、dispose 和 `turn/start` 之前的失败;reject 不会创建轮次,已记录的轮次保持边界平衡,消息不会合并,之后仍需处理的工作也能继续清空。
- 其他测试分别覆盖轮次打开时、轮次失败后和空闲时的 `steer()`,以及待处理的 `inject()`、面向整个 agent 的状态和 `whenIdle()`。
## 后果
普通轮次的边界可预测:消息 A、B 始终分开,B 只能在 A 关闭并到达检查点后运行。调用方仍然拿不到逐次 send 的完成句柄;待处理项可通过其仍有效的 `InboxItemId` 移除,广义取消可以丢弃整个尚未启动的队尾,而状态与完全停稳仍是面向整个 agent 的观察。
普通轮次的边界可预测:消息 A、B 始终分开,B 只能在 A 关闭并到达检查点后运行。调用方仍然拿不到逐次 send 的完成句柄;待处理消息可通过其 `MessageId` 移除,广义取消可以丢弃整个尚未启动的队尾,而状态与完全停稳仍是面向整个 agent 的观察。
代价是模型请求和检查点都会增加。繁忙队列可能需要更长时间才能清空;如果生产方持续提交消息,队列也可能增长。只有建立显式且经过测量的契约后,才能重新引入普通 send 批处理。

View File

@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write
2026-07-22-plan-specific-collaboration-state.md: fb26d15238f0eb1b63fdccc7e48a6c49a44236cf
2026-07-22-plan-specific-collaboration-state.zh.md: 93186eebb263458bc99e7f7562d065fbf9e5d4bf
2026-07-22-plan-specific-collaboration-state.md: d139f3d861244c80acfb604d17172461bbf0cd57
2026-07-22-plan-specific-collaboration-state.zh.md: 415e0b44a3f95d40c48ea3f4ac60da460a251f7e

View File

@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ Plan mode also needs a durable stance, a reviewable plan artifact, an explicit h
## Decision
Plan mode owns a plan-specific product package: `@deepseek-ai/dsh-plan-mode` at `packages/plan/plan-mode/`. The durable fact is `plan/mode: { active: boolean }`, folded by `foldPlanMode(events)` with `false` as the empty-log value. `ctx.planMode.get(agent)` returns `{ active, pending? }`, and `set(agent, active)` records the boundary-applied selection. The existing prompt-submit, continuation, retry, append-failure, and disposal fences remain unchanged in meaning.
Plan mode owns a plan-specific product package: `@deepseek-ai/dsh-plan-mode` at `packages/plan/plan-mode/`. The durable fact is `plan/mode: { active: boolean }`, folded by `foldPlanMode(events)` with `false` as the empty-log value. `ctx.planMode.get(agent)` returns `{ active, pending? }`, and `set(agent, active)` records the boundary-applied selection. The pre-step, retry, append-failure, and disposal fences preserve the same state-transition ownership.
Configuration is exactly `{ section: string }`. The package registers the fixed `plan:policy` section, `/plan [message]`, the exact `/plan off` direct-exit form, and `exit_plan_mode` itself. Bare `/plan` selects active; another non-empty argument selects it first and then sends the trimmed text through `agent.steer()`, making the text an ordinary logged user message in the affected step. `/plan off` selects inactive without model input and can cancel an entry that is still pending at the boundary. The exit tool remains registered while plan mode is inactive so the request tool catalog stays stable.
@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ Sandbox mode and approval policy remain separate enforcement axes. Plan mode nei
### Boundary and model contract
`plan/mode` is log-only and non-surface, so resume, fork, and compaction recover the state without a live mirror. A spawned agent begins inactive because there is no creation-time plan option. Pending user selections flush before the affected request assembly on prompt submission, ordinary continuation, or a request-recovery retry; a failed durable append leaves the intent pending for a later boundary.
`plan/mode` is log-only and non-surface, so resume, fork, and compaction recover the state without a live mirror. A spawned agent begins inactive because there is no creation-time plan option. Pending user selections flush before the affected request assembly at initial or continuation pre-step, or on a request-recovery retry; a failed durable append leaves the intent pending for a later boundary.
The active state contributes the deployment's section at prompt order 50. Inactive state contributes no section, while `exit_plan_mode` remains registered in both states, so a transition changes the logged request header but not native tool schemas or the Code Mode SDK. A user-driven transition appends one plugin-sourced notice only when the last request header described the opposite state; a pre-first-request or net-zero selection adds none, and an approved tool exit relies on its tool result instead of a second notice.

View File

@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ Plan mode 还需要持久协作状态、可评审的计划产物、显式人工
## 决策
Plan mode 拥有一个 plan 专用产品包:位于 `packages/plan/plan-mode/` 的 `@deepseek-ai/dsh-plan-mode`。持久化事实为 `plan/mode: { active: boolean }`,由 `foldPlanMode(events)` 折叠,空日志值为 `false`。`ctx.planMode.get(agent)` 返回 `{ active, pending? }`,`set(agent, active)` 则记录在边界生效的选择。现有的提示词提交、continuation、重试、追加失败和 dispose(资源释放)栅栏在语义上保持不变。
Plan mode 拥有一个 plan 专用产品包:位于 `packages/plan/plan-mode/` 的 `@deepseek-ai/dsh-plan-mode`。持久化事实为 `plan/mode: { active: boolean }`,由 `foldPlanMode(events)` 折叠,空日志值为 `false`。`ctx.planMode.get(agent)` 返回 `{ active, pending? }`,`set(agent, active)` 则记录在边界生效的选择。pre-step、重试、追加失败和 dispose(资源释放)栅栏保留相同的状态转换归属。
配置严格为 `{ section: string }`。该包自行注册固定的 `plan:policy` 段、`/plan [message]`、精确匹配的 `/plan off` 主动退出形式,以及 `exit_plan_mode`。不带参数的 `/plan` 选择激活;其他非空参数则先选择激活,再通过 `agent.steer()` 发送去除首尾空白后的文本,使该文本在受影响的步骤中成为一条记录到日志的普通用户消息。`/plan off` 选择未激活,不产生模型输入,并可取消仍待在边界生效的进入选择。即使 plan mode 未激活,退出工具仍保持注册,以确保请求工具目录稳定。
@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ Plan mode 拥有一个 plan 专用产品包:位于 `packages/plan/plan-mode/`
### 边界与模型契约
`plan/mode` 仅记录到日志且不进入表层,因此恢复、fork 和压缩都能恢复该状态,无需实时镜像。spawn 出的 agent 初始处于未激活状态,因为创建时没有 plan 选项。待生效的用户选择会在提示词提交、普通 continuation 或请求恢复重试时,于受影响的请求组装前写入日志;持久追加失败会让意图保持待定,留到后续边界处理。
`plan/mode` 仅记录到日志且不进入表层,因此恢复、fork 和压缩都能恢复该状态,无需实时镜像。spawn 出的 agent 初始处于未激活状态,因为创建时没有 plan 选项。待生效的用户选择会在初始或续步 pre-step、或请求恢复重试时,于受影响的请求组装前写入日志;持久追加失败会让意图保持待定,留到后续边界处理。
激活状态在提示词顺序 50 处贡献部署提供的区段。未激活状态不贡献区段,但 `exit_plan_mode` 在两种状态下都保持注册,因此状态转换会改变已记录的请求头,却不改变原生工具 schema 或 Code Mode SDK。用户发起的转换只会在上一条请求头描述相反状态时追加一条来源为插件的通知;第一次请求前的选择或最终状态未变化的选择不会追加通知,经批准的工具退出则依赖其工具结果,不再追加第二条通知。

View File

@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write .agents/notes/implemented/simplification/2026-07-24-agent-loop-observable-state-machine.md
2026-07-24-agent-loop-observable-state-machine.md: 2024662495d8396e946e7c43f010164cd9414b83
2026-07-24-agent-loop-observable-state-machine.zh.md: dc83a310ff2d7945e6b7e79625224102f0f4871c
2026-07-24-agent-loop-observable-state-machine.md: b1773fdf7fd3bcbea9c6b9a4a0ce37c715bce4ca
2026-07-24-agent-loop-observable-state-machine.zh.md: cdbddff97f21fbe3fc921ef480cda2f293d1f758

View File

@@ -18,16 +18,16 @@ The public contract exposes four orthogonal state dimensions:
- Registration lifetime is the `agent/created` to `agent/disposed` interval. Disposal is the terminal registry edge, not an `AgentStatus`.
- Whole-agent activity is `AgentStatus = 'idle' | 'running'`. Consecutive turns may share one `running` interval.
- A FIFO-backed message progresses from `agent/inbox/enqueue` to exactly one `agent/inbox/dequeue` or `agent/inbox/discard`. Enqueue and dequeue correlate an occurrence by `MessageId` plus its queued-or-steering placement; same-placement repeats retire in FIFO order. The inbox events describe acceptance, claim, and removal rather than turn completion.
- A claimed turn passes through prompt admission and zero or more request steps. An automatic retry closes the failed turn and immediately opens another; `agent/settled` reports only the terminal turn in that chain and remains distinct from the whole-agent transition to `status === 'idle'`.
- A pending message emits `agent/inbox/inserted` when inserted, then either `agent/inbox/claimed` after an atomic pure-deletion claim or `agent/inbox/discarded` after an ordinary removal. `MessageId` correlates the exact message; durable splice coordinates retain placement and cancellation. Inbox events describe insertion, claim, and discard rather than turn completion.
- A claimed turn passes through pre-step entry and zero or more request steps. An automatic retry closes the failed turn and immediately opens another; `agent/settled` reports only the terminal turn in that chain and remains distinct from the whole-agent transition to `status === 'idle'`.
The loop keeps five machine extension events. `agent/prompt-submit` admits, rewrites, or blocks a claimed prompt. `agent/step` is the single awaited between-steps checkpoint and runs before every request is derived. `agent/request` is the waterfall for the frozen call configuration; the configuration comes only from `await next()`, not from a duplicate positional argument. `agent/request-error` serializes ownership of awaited model-request recovery. `agent/turn-stopping` runs when the turn otherwise has no work left; a listener that needs another step records real steering with `agent.steer()`, and the loop decides from that data after all listeners settle.
The loop keeps four machine extension events. `agent/pre-step` decides reject or enter for one exclusive claimed batch and runs before every proposed step. `agent/request` is the waterfall for the frozen call configuration; the configuration comes only from `await next()`, not from a duplicate positional argument. `agent/request-error` serializes ownership of awaited model-request recovery. `agent/turn-stopping` runs when the turn otherwise has no work left; a listener that needs another step records real steering with `agent.steer()`, and the loop decides from that data after all listeners settle.
Continuation and termination are data rather than returned control enums. Tool calls and accepted steering require another step. A tool result carrying `concludesTurn` ends the tool loop at its step. The loop does not expose general `ContinuationDecision` or terminal-stop return channels.
A model-request failure closes its step, then enters `agent/request-error` with the exact error, normalized `LlmFailure`, and live turn signal. A listener that owns recovery repairs state, returns `{ kind: 'retry' }`, and stops delegating. The loop closes the failed turn and opens one retry turn over that state without an intervening idle notification; retry is not another step inside the failed turn. `agent/settled` reports the terminal outcome, and `agent/error` remains the live error notification for consumers that report failures independently of turn settlement. The [retry-action decision](2026-07-27-request-error-retry-action.md) supersedes the command-shaped part of this design.
The event taxonomy removes `agent/pre-step`, `agent/post-step`, `agent/session-prefix`, `agent/step-result`, `agent/turn-continuation`, and `agent/turn-stop`. Durable turn and step boundaries remain session events. Model-facing additions use logged message channels, request configuration uses `agent/request`, response content is recorded as assembled, failed-request recovery uses the `agent/request-error` return action, and end-of-turn continuation uses `agent/turn-stopping` plus steering.
The event taxonomy removes the legacy prompt preparation/submission and serial step hooks together with `agent/post-step`, `agent/session-prefix`, `agent/step-result`, `agent/turn-continuation`, and `agent/turn-stop`. The single `agent/pre-step` waterfall owns claimed-message entry. Durable turn and step boundaries remain session events. Model-facing additions use logged message channels, request configuration uses `agent/request`, response content is recorded as assembled, failed-request recovery uses the `agent/request-error` return action, and end-of-turn continuation uses `agent/turn-stopping` plus steering.
## Alternatives considered

View File

@@ -18,16 +18,16 @@ agent 生命周期、agent 整体活动状态、收件箱条目的进度以及
- 注册生命周期是从 `agent/created` 到 `agent/disposed` 的区间。dispose(资源释放)是注册表的终止边界,而不是一种 `AgentStatus`。
- agent 整体活动状态为 `AgentStatus = 'idle' | 'running'`。连续多个轮次可以共用同一个 `running` 区间。
- 由 FIFO 支撑的消息从 `agent/inbox/enqueue` 开始,最终必然进入 `agent/inbox/dequeue` 或 `agent/inbox/discard` 二者之一。enqueue 与 dequeue 通过 `MessageId` 加 queued 或 steering(中途引导)放置方式关联一次消息出现;放置方式相同的重复项按 FIFO 顺序结算。收件箱事件描述接受、领取和移除,而不是轮次完成。
- 已领取的轮次经过提示词准入和零个或多个请求步骤。自动重试会关闭失败轮次并立即开启另一个轮次;`agent/settled` 只报告该重试链的终态轮次,且仍不同于 agent 整体转换到 `status === 'idle'`。
- 待处理消息插入时会发出 `agent/inbox/inserted`,随后要么在原子纯删除领取后发出 `agent/inbox/claimed`,要么在普通删除后发出 `agent/inbox/discarded`。`MessageId` 关联确切消息;持久 splice 坐标保留 placement 与取消信息。inbox 事件描述插入、领取和丢弃,而不是轮次完成。
- 已领取的轮次经过 pre-step 进入决策和零个或多个请求步骤。自动重试会关闭失败轮次并立即开启另一个轮次;`agent/settled` 只报告该重试链的终态轮次,且仍不同于 agent 整体转换到 `status === 'idle'`。
循环保留五个状态机扩展事件。`agent/prompt-submit` 对已领取的提示词执行准入、改写或阻断。`agent/step` 是步骤之间唯一需要等待的检查点,在每次派生请求前运行。`agent/request` 是冻结调用配置所用的 waterfall;配置只能来自 `await next()`,不再通过重复的位置参数提供。`agent/request-error` 串行确定需要等待的模型请求恢复由谁负责。当轮次原本已经没有剩余工作时,`agent/turn-stopping` 运行;需要再执行一个步骤的监听器使用 `agent.steer()` 记录真实的 steering,循环在所有监听器完成后根据这份数据作出决定。
循环保留四个状态机扩展事件。`agent/pre-step` 对独占的已领取批次执行 reject 或 enter 决策,并在每个拟议步骤前运行。`agent/request` 是冻结调用配置所用的 waterfall;配置只能来自 `await next()`,不再通过重复的位置参数提供。`agent/request-error` 串行确定需要等待的模型请求恢复由谁负责。当轮次原本已经没有剩余工作时,`agent/turn-stopping` 运行;需要再执行一个步骤的监听器使用 `agent.steer()` 记录真实的 steering,循环在所有监听器完成后根据这份数据作出决定。
是否继续和终止执行由数据表达,不再由返回的控制枚举表达。工具调用和已接受的 steering 要求再执行一个步骤。携带 `concludesTurn` 的工具结果会在其所属步骤终止工具循环。循环不再暴露通用的 `ContinuationDecision` 或终止停止返回通道。
模型请求失败会先关闭当前步骤,再携带准确错误、标准化 `LlmFailure` 和仍有效的轮次信号进入 `agent/request-error`。负责恢复的监听器修复状态、返回 `{ kind: 'retry' }`,并停止继续委托。循环会关闭失败轮次,并基于该状态开启一个重试轮次,中间不发布空闲通知;重试不是失败轮次内的另一个步骤。`agent/settled` 报告终态结果;对于需要脱离轮次结算单独报告失败的消费方,`agent/error` 仍作为实时错误通知保留。[重试动作决策](2026-07-27-request-error-retry-action.md)取代了本设计中命令形式的部分。
事件分类体系移除了 `agent/pre-step`、`agent/post-step`、`agent/session-prefix`、`agent/step-result`、`agent/turn-continuation` 和 `agent/turn-stop`。持久的轮次与步骤边界仍由会话事件记录。面向模型的新增内容使用有日志记录的消息通道,请求配置使用 `agent/request`,响应内容按组装后的原样记录,失败请求恢复使用 `agent/request-error` 返回动作,轮次结束时是否继续则使用 `agent/turn-stopping` 加 steering 表达。
事件分类体系移除了旧的提示词准备/提交与串行 step hook,以及 `agent/post-step`、`agent/session-prefix`、`agent/step-result`、`agent/turn-continuation` 和 `agent/turn-stop`。唯一的 `agent/pre-step` waterfall 负责已领取消息能否进入步骤。持久的轮次与步骤边界仍由会话事件记录。面向模型的新增内容使用有日志记录的消息通道,请求配置使用 `agent/request`,响应内容按组装后的原样记录,失败请求恢复使用 `agent/request-error` 返回动作,轮次结束时是否继续则使用 `agent/turn-stopping` 加 steering 表达。
## 考虑过的替代方案

View File

@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write .agents/notes/implemented/simplification/2026-07-28-remove-synthetic-log-only-turns.md
2026-07-28-remove-synthetic-log-only-turns.md: af4da00f4fe1d7aebff845cd55053bb5b807c979
2026-07-28-remove-synthetic-log-only-turns.zh.md: 9d72781d6b7cf396a830790d108f4ff25adc816a
2026-07-28-remove-synthetic-log-only-turns.md: eebb4bcfe42ca8aecac01a86e9d0c265ce57cfec
2026-07-28-remove-synthetic-log-only-turns.zh.md: a6278316ec4c946c51829d585f2854bd8aed4e13

View File

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ English | [中文](2026-07-28-remove-synthetic-log-only-turns.zh.md)
The session store exposed `appendOutOfBand()` so a plugin could publish a late log-only event while no agent turn was running. The method wrapped that event in `turn/start` and `turn/end`, then flushed it. This preserved the old rule that every durable event had to live inside a turn, but it made one identifier mean both a model-loop execution and a persistence-only update.
That rule was introduced when persistence recovery treated the last `turn/end` as the only committed boundary. The persistence scanners now preserve every valid contiguous event, and crash repair reacts only to an actually open turn. Idle context already uses the same capability by appending `user/message` between turns. Retaining synthetic turns for title updates therefore inflated turn counts, produced execution outcomes for work that never ran the model, and let a late metadata write consume the next turn number.
That rule was introduced when persistence recovery treated the last `turn/end` as the only committed boundary. The persistence scanners now preserve every valid contiguous event, and crash repair reacts only to an actually open turn. Retaining synthetic turns for title updates therefore inflated turn counts, produced execution outcomes for work that never ran the model, and let a late metadata write consume the next turn number.
The generic seam also duplicated domain policy. Its marker map said which plugin events were eligible, while the title capability already owned cancellation, liveness, and stale-result rules. Replacing it with another generic or title-specific append wrapper would preserve the same type indirection for two literal event types.
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ Core session invariants continue to enforce core-owned execution relations: turn
The title service appends `session/title` directly after its existing service, revision, cancellation, and live-session checks. The bundled model helper appends its literal `session/title-llm-request` record before dispatch. Persistence observes both through the eager `session/event` path and drains them at ordinary checkpoints and lifecycle teardown; neither append forces a flush merely because it is between turns. A fallback, auxiliary request record, or accepted provider title may therefore appear after `turn/end` and before the next `turn/start`.
A session fork may end at any stable event position outside an open turn, not only at `turn/end`. This preserves standalone title and context records in a default fork while still rejecting a prefix cut through active execution.
A session fork may end at any stable event position outside an open turn, not only at `turn/end`. This preserves standalone title and other plugin-owned log-only records in a default fork while still rejecting a prefix cut through active execution.
The historical [universal turn-enclosure decision](../../archived/architecture/2026-06-15-turn-enclosure-invariant.md) remains useful only as the reason the synthetic mechanism was introduced. The [context-injection decision](../architecture/2026-07-24-separate-context-injection-from-turn-execution.md) established the current meaning: one turn represents one model-loop execution.

View File

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ Status: implemented
会话存储曾暴露 `appendOutOfBand()`,让插件可以在没有 agent(智能体)轮次运行时发布延迟到达的纯日志事件。该方法会用 `turn/start` 和 `turn/end` 包住事件,再将其刷写。这保留了「每个持久事件都必须位于轮次内」的旧规则,却让同一个标识符既表示模型循环执行,又表示仅持久化更新。
引入该规则时,持久化恢复曾将最后一个 `turn/end` 视为唯一的已提交边界。如今,持久化扫描器会保留每个合法且连续的事件,崩溃修复也只处理确实处于开放状态的轮次。空闲上下文早已采用同一机制,在轮次之间追加 `user/message`。因此,为标题更新保留合成轮次会夸大轮次计数、为从未运行模型的工作产生执行结果,还会让延迟到达的元数据写入占用下一个轮次编号。
引入该规则时,持久化恢复曾将最后一个 `turn/end` 视为唯一的已提交边界。如今,持久化扫描器会保留每个合法且连续的事件,崩溃修复也只处理确实处于开放状态的轮次。因此,为标题更新保留合成轮次会夸大轮次计数、为从未运行模型的工作产生执行结果,还会让延迟到达的元数据写入占用下一个轮次编号。
通用 seam 还重复了领域策略。它的标记映射说明哪些插件事件符合条件,而标题功能本就拥有取消、活跃性和陈旧结果处理规则。改用另一个通用或标题专属追加包装层,仍会为两个字面量事件类型保留同一层类型间接性。
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ Status: implemented
标题服务会在完成既有的服务状态、修订、取消和实时会话检查后,直接追加 `session/title`。随附模型辅助函数会在发起调用前追加其字面量 `session/title-llm-request` 记录。持久化通过尽快处理的 `session/event` 路径观察两者,并在常规检查点与生命周期 teardown 时排空;二者都不会仅因为位于轮次之间就强制 flush。因此,回退标题、辅助请求记录或已接受的提供方标题可以出现在 `turn/end` 之后、下一个 `turn/start` 之前。
会话 fork 可以结束于开放轮次之外的任意稳定事件位置,而不限于 `turn/end`。这样,默认 fork 会保留独立标题和上下文记录,同时仍拒绝在活跃执行过程中截断前缀。
会话 fork 可以结束于开放轮次之外的任意稳定事件位置,而不限于 `turn/end`。这样,默认 fork 会保留独立标题和其他插件所属的纯日志记录,同时仍拒绝在活跃执行过程中截断前缀。
历史上的[通用轮次封闭决策](../../archived/architecture/2026-06-15-turn-enclosure-invariant.md)如今只适合用于解释为何曾引入合成机制。[上下文注入决策](../architecture/2026-07-24-separate-context-injection-from-turn-execution.md)确立了当前语义:一个轮次表示一次模型循环执行。