docs: reject the landstrip evaluation for the win32 sandbox rung

User verdict: landstrip is not battle-tested — a days-old,
single-maintainer project (~48 GitHub stars at rejection), which a
security-invariant dependency cannot be. The note moves
proposed/feature -> rejected/feature with the verdict on the Status
line; the sandbox note's deferred-phases cross-link now records the
rejection instead of instructing an evaluation, and the NIH roll-up's
pointer follows. Supersedes this branch's earlier cross-link commit.
This commit is contained in:
Tianyi Cui
2026-07-27 00:55:32 +08:00
parent d0b87e8c0f
commit f520479663
9 changed files with 12 additions and 12 deletions

View File

@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write
2026-07-26-dependency-swaps-rejected-by-nih-audit.md: c988ca0c75e9c50686551f3be1971d736b971e2a
2026-07-26-dependency-swaps-rejected-by-nih-audit.zh.md: e85161cb2ee616d388aa2a9dd065c315c60cd44a
2026-07-26-dependency-swaps-rejected-by-nih-audit.md: 92ecfeef2deb7f6cca6e99b4e2de7571bc974548
2026-07-26-dependency-swaps-rejected-by-nih-audit.zh.md: 76f9c012e8986fc8b527cab263f875983bd72609

View File

@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ Adopt the following dependency swaps. Rejected — per-item evidence below; a fu
- **`syncpack`/`manypkg` for `check-workspace-constraints.ts`**: they cover ~20 lines of range alignment; the load-bearing 200+ lines (computed `files` lists, cordis peer=dev pairing, hierarchy shape) are repo policy no generic engine expresses.
- **`remark-validate-links` for `verify-md-links.ts`**: the gate rides the repo's shared mdast toolchain; adopting remark-cli adds a second markdown stack to delete one small file.
- **`prebuildify`/`node-gyp-build` for the landlock launcher packaging**: inapplicable — those load `.node` addons via dlopen; the launcher ships a standalone exec'd static binary, and per-platform `optionalDependencies` *is* the ecosystem convention for binaries.
- **Replacing the Landlock launcher itself with `@landstrip/landstrip`**: fails the security-invariant test — the launcher is a ~300-line reviewable C file with byte-pinned provenance that already migrated away from a Rust dependency; a single-maintainer LGPL Rust binary set is a larger audit surface with weaker provenance. (The unbuilt Windows rung is a different question — see the [landstrip evaluation proposal](../../proposed/feature/2026-07-26-evaluate-landstrip-for-windows-sandbox-rung.md).)
- **Replacing the Landlock launcher itself with `@landstrip/landstrip`**: fails the security-invariant test — the launcher is a ~300-line reviewable C file with byte-pinned provenance that already migrated away from a Rust dependency; a single-maintainer LGPL Rust binary set is a larger audit surface with weaker provenance. (The unbuilt Windows rung was weighed separately and also [rejected](../feature/2026-07-26-evaluate-landstrip-for-windows-sandbox-rung.md) — landstrip is not battle-tested.)
- **`hatch-nodejs-version` for Python release versioning**: roughly LOC-neutral (a custom metadata hook replaces the regex), inverts the recorded decision that the dev sentinel never determines a release version, and puts a single-maintainer build plugin in the release supply chain.
- **YAML consolidation (`js-yaml` vs `yaml`)**: the repo carries both parsers, with the `!!js` tag defined three times on js-yaml (vendored include, app-boot, apps/cli) and twice on `yaml` (sdk-telemetry's `ScalarTag`, sdk-helper's comment-preserving Document editing). The direction is forced — js-yaml cannot replace `yaml` (sdk-helper needs the Document API) — but migrating the js-yaml sites cannot retire the library either (the vendored include pins it) and would put two parsers in charge of one dialect that must agree exactly, against the [personal-config note](../../implemented/feature/2026-07-20-dsh-cli-personal-config.md)'s deliberate load-only-copy parity. Deletable: ~2025 lines of duplicate tag definitions and two `@types/js-yaml` entries. The consolidation moment is a future include sync, not now.

View File

@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ Status: rejected — 下列每一项替换在证据上都未达到净简化门
- **以 `syncpack`/`manypkg` 替换 `check-workspace-constraints.ts`**:它们只覆盖约 20 行的版本范围对齐;承重的 200+ 行(计算生成的 `files` 列表、cordis peer=dev 配对、层级形状)是仓库政策,没有通用引擎能表达。
- **以 `remark-validate-links` 替换 `verify-md-links.ts`**:该门禁搭载仓库共享的 mdast 工具链;采用 remark-cli 等于为删掉一个小文件而增加第二套 markdown 技术栈。
- **以 `prebuildify`/`node-gyp-build` 承担 landlock 启动器打包**:不适用——那些工具通过 dlopen 加载 `.node` addon这个启动器交付的是独立 exec 的静态二进制,而按平台划分的 `optionalDependencies` 恰恰*就是*二进制分发的生态惯例。
- **以 `@landstrip/landstrip` 替换 Landlock 启动器本身**:未通过安全不变式检验——启动器是一个约 300 行、可完整评审、来源逐字节锁定的 C 文件,且早已从一个 Rust 依赖迁移出来;单一维护者的 LGPL Rust 二进制集合是更大的审计面加更弱的来源保障。(尚未构建的 Windows 层级是另一个问题——见 [landstrip 评估提案](../../proposed/feature/2026-07-26-evaluate-landstrip-for-windows-sandbox-rung.md)。)
- **以 `@landstrip/landstrip` 替换 Landlock 启动器本身**:未通过安全不变式检验——启动器是一个约 300 行、可完整评审、来源逐字节锁定的 C 文件,且早已从一个 Rust 依赖迁移出来;单一维护者的 LGPL Rust 二进制集合是更大的审计面加更弱的来源保障。(尚未构建的 Windows 层级经单独权衡后同样被[驳回](../feature/2026-07-26-evaluate-landstrip-for-windows-sandbox-rung.md)——landstrip 未经实战检验。)
- **以 `hatch-nodejs-version` 承担 Python 发布版本号**:代码行数大致持平(一个自定义 metadata 钩子换掉那个正则却反转了「dev 哨兵值绝不决定发布版本」这条记录在案的决策,还把一个单一维护者的构建插件放进发布供应链。
- **YAML 归一(`js-yaml``yaml`**:仓库同时携带两个解析器,`!!js` 标签在 js-yaml 上定义了三次vendor 收录的 include、app-boot、apps/cli`yaml` 上定义了两次sdk-telemetry 的 `ScalarTag`、sdk-helper 的保留注释式 Document 编辑。方向是被迫的——js-yaml 无法取代 `yaml`sdk-helper 需要 Document API——但迁移 js-yaml 各调用点也退休不了这个库vendor 收录的 include 锁定了它),还会让两个解析器共管一种必须完全一致的方言,违背[个人配置决策](../../implemented/feature/2026-07-20-dsh-cli-personal-config.md)刻意的「仅加载副本」对等性。可删除的:约 2025 行重复标签定义和两条 `@types/js-yaml` 条目。归一的时机是未来某次 include 同步,不是现在。