docs: harden pairing gate per review — structural signature, not counts
Review findings addressed: - The gate compared only heading and code-block COUNTS, understating the contract it claims to enforce. It now compares ordered structural signatures: heading depths, fenced code blocks verbatim (info string + content), table column counts, list kinds, and every link target except the language switcher. Proven red on a heading demotion, a reworded code-block comment, and a retargeted link; green on all existing pairs. - Stated the gate's limit explicitly (header comment + docs/i18n/README.md both languages): green means fresh and structurally sound, NOT verified — translation quality is the reviewer's half of the contract. - first-line extraction no longer silently drops the last character of a newline-less file (split with limit instead of indexOf slice). - isExcluded documents the trailing-slash-is-the-boundary invariant. - Rollout guidance: grow the required frontier at the pace translation review is resourced. - dsh-code-review's doc-sync sublist is now the exhaustive chain. docs/i18n/README.zh.md updated via the minimal-diff workflow and re-fingerprinted.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ These come straight from the source docs above. They are not discretionary; abse
|
||||
1. **Docs in sync.** If the PR changes a config key, default, error code, wire field, or event name, it must update the package README + module/JSDoc in the same diff. The `doc-sync` gate (check #4) does not catch prose drift in config keys, defaults, error codes, or wire fields — that is on the reviewer, but it is still required, not optional.
|
||||
2. **Core-data-structures catalog in sync.** If the PR adds, removes, or reshapes a type the [core-data-structures catalog](../../../docs/core-data-structures/core.md) documents — a new `…Map` variant, a new content-block/session-event type, a field on `GenerateOptions`/`Agent`/`ToolDefinition`/a bash type, or a whole new core/seam type — it must update that catalog in the same diff (prose + any verbatim ` ```ts type-equiv ` block + the 1:1 `scripts/type-equiv.manifest.json`). The `verify-type-equiv` gate (part of `doc-sync`) catches a *drifted paste* of an already-documented type, but it cannot tell you a brand-new core type went undocumented — that judgment is yours. Confirm a genuinely spine-level type landed in core.md and a new capability's vocabulary on a sub-page, per the spine-vs-seam line in [core.md § What counts as "core"](../../../docs/core-data-structures/core.md#what-counts-as-core). A pure internal type with no cross-package reach needs no catalog entry — say so if it's a judgment call.
|
||||
3. **HMR-safety test.** Any new registry/registration needs a test that disposes the contributing fiber and asserts cleanup (packages/AGENTS.md). Its absence blocks merge.
|
||||
4. **Quality gates pass.** typecheck, lint, test, test:coverage (100% per-file on `packages/*/src`), knip, build, publint, constraints, `doc-sync` (doc-typecheck + verify-cordis-catalog + verify-md-wrap + verify-md-links + verify-type-equiv + verify-translation-pairing), module-graph freshness (the quality-gates RFC). Don't re-review what a gate already enforces — trust the gate and spend attention on what it can't check. Note that the `doc-sync` gate only covers compilable `ts` blocks, the generated cordis events/services catalog, markdown wrapping/links, verbatim type-equiv blocks, and the bilingual pairing contract ([docs/i18n/README.md](../../../docs/i18n/README.md)); prose drift (checks #1 and #2) and translation *quality* (the [dsh-translate-docs](../dsh-translate-docs/SKILL.md) rules) are *additional* manual review on top of it, not covered by it.
|
||||
4. **Quality gates pass.** typecheck, lint, test, test:coverage (100% per-file on `packages/*/src`), knip, build, publint, constraints, `doc-sync` (doc-typecheck + verify-cordis-catalog + verify-tool-catalog + verify-md-wrap + verify-md-links + verify-doc-refs + verify-package-paths + verify-rfc-classification + verify-type-equiv + verify-translation-pairing), module-graph freshness (the quality-gates RFC). Don't re-review what a gate already enforces — trust the gate and spend attention on what it can't check. Note that the `doc-sync` gate only covers compilable `ts` blocks, the generated cordis events/services catalog, markdown wrapping/links, verbatim type-equiv blocks, and the bilingual pairing contract ([docs/i18n/README.md](../../../docs/i18n/README.md)); prose drift (checks #1 and #2) and translation *quality* (the [dsh-translate-docs](../dsh-translate-docs/SKILL.md) rules) are *additional* manual review on top of it, not covered by it.
|
||||
|
||||
## Reviewer-only checks (gates can't catch these — judgment required)
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user