refactor(agent): scope queue actions to edit and remove
This commit is contained in:
@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
|
||||
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
|
||||
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
|
||||
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write .agents/notes/implemented/architecture/2026-07-22-unified-send-and-coalesced-user-messages.md
|
||||
2026-07-22-unified-send-and-coalesced-user-messages.md: 3b2187f9e9ae24f3a03c1418daf1c0aec255b314
|
||||
2026-07-22-unified-send-and-coalesced-user-messages.zh.md: 02a21193ce63926b6f04a02cb7ea8a64fe6603cb
|
||||
2026-07-22-unified-send-and-coalesced-user-messages.md: 4d0cbeff0c8a07362caa1ec18493267a9f0d2823
|
||||
2026-07-22-unified-send-and-coalesced-user-messages.zh.md: 935a1a78a6bed451c1db646dec2ec5f4f5e87949
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ Separately, `context/message` and `user/message` had converged: the surface proj
|
||||
|
||||
**`send` does not return identity.** Callers already own the complete message and its opaque `MessageId`; creation and freezing are owned by the [identified immutable message decision](2026-07-28-identified-immutable-message-values.md), not by routing.
|
||||
|
||||
**Inbox lifecycle events carry occurrence identities.** `agent/inbox/enqueue` (an item entered a FIFO), `agent/inbox/update` (a pending item was edited or promoted), `agent/inbox/dequeue` (the driver claimed one), and `agent/inbox/discard` (pending items were dropped) carry an `InboxItem`: an occurrence-local `InboxItemId`, the accepted `UserMessage`, and the resolved `queued | steering` placement captured at acceptance. The occurrence identity lets observers and reconnect mirrors distinguish repeated sends of the same `MessageId` without reconstructing routing from later status or session history. Injection never touches a FIFO and emits none of these. Every FIFO entry publishes one enqueue and exactly one terminal dequeue or discard; updates are non-terminal. The `dsh-agent` invariant companion asserts this FIFO conservation.
|
||||
**Inbox lifecycle events carry occurrence identities.** `agent/inbox/enqueue` (an item entered a FIFO), `agent/inbox/update` (a pending queued item was edited), `agent/inbox/dequeue` (the driver claimed one), and `agent/inbox/discard` (pending items were dropped) carry an `InboxItem`: an occurrence-local `InboxItemId`, the accepted `UserMessage`, and the resolved `queued | steering` placement captured at acceptance. The occurrence identity lets observers and reconnect mirrors distinguish repeated sends of the same `MessageId` without reconstructing routing from later status or session history. Injection never touches a FIFO and emits none of these. Every FIFO entry publishes one enqueue and exactly one terminal dequeue or discard; updates are non-terminal. The `dsh-agent` invariant companion asserts this FIFO conservation.
|
||||
|
||||
**Admission accepts next-step input without becoming a turn.** The loop opens a private next-step acceptance window before `agent/prompt-submit`, keeps it open through the turn, and closes it before `turn/end`. Steering and injection received during admission therefore remain together in the outbox and join an allowed turn. If admission blocks or fails, a context-only caller batch takes idle injection's immediate append, while steering and context staged beside it remain available to retry; neither path writes the rejected prompt. When a later prompt is admitted, retained outbox input enters its turn before that prompt, while input accepted during the current admission remains after the prompt. Closing the window before `turn/end` preserves the rule that reentrant late steering becomes an independent queued turn. `Agent.acceptsNextStep` exposes whether a `next-step` send would currently join this window; `status` remains the broader activity signal rather than a routing predicate.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ agent 的对外驱动接口逐渐长出三个近乎平行的动词——`send`
|
||||
|
||||
**`send` 不返回标识。** 调用方已经持有完整消息及其不透明的 `MessageId`;消息的创建与冻结由[带标识的不可变消息值决策](2026-07-28-identified-immutable-message-values.md)负责,而不是由路由负责。
|
||||
|
||||
**Inbox 生命周期事件携带单次入队标识。** `agent/inbox/enqueue`(一个队列项进入某个 FIFO)、`agent/inbox/update`(待处理项被编辑或前移)、`agent/inbox/dequeue`(驱动器认领一个项)和 `agent/inbox/discard`(待处理项被丢弃)都会携带一个 `InboxItem`:仅属于本次入队的 `InboxItemId`、已接受的 `UserMessage`,以及生产方在接受消息时捕获的已解析 `queued | steering` 放置方式。单次入队标识让观察方和重连镜像能够区分同一 `MessageId` 的多次发送,无需根据后续状态或会话历史重建路由。注入从不触及 FIFO,也不发出这些事件中的任何一个。每次 FIFO 入队都会发布一个 enqueue,并且恰好发布一个终态 dequeue 或 discard;update 不是终态。`dsh-agent` 的不变量配套断言这种 FIFO 守恒。
|
||||
**Inbox 生命周期事件携带单次入队标识。** `agent/inbox/enqueue`(一个队列项进入某个 FIFO)、`agent/inbox/update`(待处理的 queued 项被编辑)、`agent/inbox/dequeue`(驱动器认领一个项)和 `agent/inbox/discard`(待处理项被丢弃)都会携带一个 `InboxItem`:仅属于本次入队的 `InboxItemId`、已接受的 `UserMessage`,以及生产方在接受消息时捕获的已解析 `queued | steering` 放置方式。单次入队标识让观察方和重连镜像能够区分同一 `MessageId` 的多次发送,无需根据后续状态或会话历史重建路由。注入从不触及 FIFO,也不发出这些事件中的任何一个。每次 FIFO 入队都会发布一个 enqueue,并且恰好发布一个终态 dequeue 或 discard;update 不是终态。`dsh-agent` 的不变量配套断言这种 FIFO 守恒。
|
||||
|
||||
**准入接受 next-step 输入,但不会因此成为一个轮次。** 循环会在 `agent/prompt-submit` 前打开一个私有的 next-step 接受窗口,使其贯穿整个轮次,并在 `turn/end` 前关闭。因此,在准入期间收到的 steering 和注入会一起留在 outbox 中并加入获准轮次。如果准入被阻止或失败,仅含调用方上下文的批次会采用空闲注入的立即追加行为,而 steering 及与其一同暂存的上下文仍可重试;两种路径都不会写入被拒绝的提示词。后续提示词获准时,保留在 outbox 中的输入会先于该提示词进入其轮次,而当前准入期间接受的输入则留在提示词之后。在 `turn/end` 前关闭窗口,可以保留这样的规则:可重入的晚到 steering 会成为一个独立的排队轮次。`Agent.acceptsNextStep` 会公开一次 `next-step` 发送当前是否会加入该窗口;`status` 仍是更宽泛的活动信号,而非路由判据。
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
|
||||
# side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
|
||||
# after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
|
||||
# pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write .agents/notes/implemented/feature/2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.md
|
||||
2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.md: 7462b882dde0c3b25ddfb321ab339b6cd51bd170
|
||||
2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.zh.md: ac442421a1e21b2e09bb003ca9be1a0412374d7f
|
||||
2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.md: 93b11dc590728a3c236971fbadf9c7c0187d943c
|
||||
2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.zh.md: 3a8e46946ad8cbe122bc3d89c6b470654ea97baf
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
|
||||
# Agent Note: Address pending queue occurrences for edit, remove, and promotion
|
||||
# Agent Note: Address pending queue occurrences for edit and removal
|
||||
|
||||
Status: implemented
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -6,19 +6,17 @@ English | [中文](2026-07-29-addressable-queue-operations.zh.md)
|
||||
|
||||
## Problem
|
||||
|
||||
The Web queue rendered pending messages but could not act on one row. `MessageId` was insufficient as an address because callers may enqueue the same immutable message more than once. The browser also inferred queue retirement from turn and status events, so a row operation racing with driver claim had no authoritative outcome.
|
||||
|
||||
“Send now” introduced a separate semantic choice: it could mean reorder the next independent turn, interrupt the current turn as steering, or cancel current work. Only the first interpretation preserves the queue row’s original delivery contract.
|
||||
The Web queue rendered pending messages but could not edit or delete one row. `MessageId` was insufficient as an address because callers may enqueue the same immutable message more than once. The browser also inferred queue retirement from turn and status events, so a row operation racing with driver claim had no authoritative outcome.
|
||||
|
||||
## Decision
|
||||
|
||||
**Each accepted FIFO occurrence has its own identity.** AgentLoop mints an opaque `InboxItemId` and publishes an `InboxItem` containing that id, the identified `UserMessage`, and its acceptance-time `queued | steering` placement. Reusing one `MessageId` creates distinct inbox identities. Injection bypasses the FIFOs and receives no inbox identity.
|
||||
|
||||
**Mutation ends at driver claim.** `Agent.updateInbox(id, action)` synchronously searches the pending queued and steering FIFOs. Edit replaces frozen content while preserving `InboxItemId`, `MessageId`, source, placement, wake policy, and position. Remove emits the occurrence’s terminal discard. Promote moves it to the front of its current FIFO; an ordinary queued item also becomes waking. The driver removes an occurrence before prompt admission or steering drain, so a later mutation returns `not-found` and never rewrites durable history.
|
||||
**Mutation ends at driver claim.** `Agent.updateInbox(id, action)` synchronously searches the pending queued FIFO. Edit replaces frozen content while preserving `InboxItemId`, `MessageId`, source, wake policy, and position. Remove emits the occurrence’s terminal discard. Steering and driver-claimed occurrences return `not-found`, so queue operations never rewrite active-turn input or durable history.
|
||||
|
||||
**The live ledger is authoritative.** `agent/inbox/enqueue`, `update`, `dequeue`, and `discard` maintain a Host mirror. The wire sends complete `session/queue` snapshots rather than incremental guesses. Reconnect sends the current baseline, and every live mutation or terminal event replaces it. The client applies no optimistic edit and never retires a row from `turn/start`, `steering/message`, or status changes.
|
||||
**The live ledger is authoritative.** `agent/inbox/enqueue`, `update`, `dequeue`, and `discard` maintain a Host mirror of queued occurrences. The wire sends complete `session/queue` snapshots rather than incremental guesses. Reconnect sends the current baseline, and every queued mutation or terminal event replaces it. The client applies no optimistic edit and never retires a row from durable turn events or status changes.
|
||||
|
||||
**Web actions preserve delivery kind.** QueueDock projects only `queued` occurrences; pending `steering` occurrences remain in the authoritative snapshot but wait for a dedicated Web interaction. It exposes edit and delete, but no send-now control. Edit is available only when all content blocks are text; the editor cannot silently drop non-text blocks. An editing row exposes only save and cancel, with Enter and Escape as their keyboard equivalents. Delete removes the exact occurrence. Protocol-level promotion remains available without being presented as a Web interaction; it never converts queued work into steering or cancels active work.
|
||||
**Web actions address Queue only.** The Host excludes pending steering from `session/queue`; steering retains its existing durable transcript path after consumption. QueueDock exposes edit and delete, but no send-now control. Edit is available only when all content blocks are text; the editor cannot silently drop non-text blocks. An editing row exposes only save and cancel, with Enter and Escape as their keyboard equivalents. Delete removes the exact occurrence.
|
||||
|
||||
## Alternatives considered
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -26,16 +24,16 @@ The Web queue rendered pending messages but could not act on one row. `MessageId
|
||||
|
||||
**Apply optimistic browser mutations.** Rejected because driver claim and another client can win before the Host action. Waiting for the authoritative snapshot makes the ownership boundary visible and lets `queue-item-not-found` report a real race.
|
||||
|
||||
**Treat send-now as steering.** Rejected because it would change a queued independent turn into current-turn context, bypass ordinary prompt admission, and alter the one-send-one-turn guarantee. Promotion changes priority, not delivery semantics.
|
||||
**Include pending steering in the queue mutation protocol.** Rejected because QueueDock has no steering interaction, and editing or deleting active-turn input would widen this feature beyond its current consumer. A dedicated steering interaction owns that delivery contract.
|
||||
|
||||
**Cancel the active turn before promotion.** Rejected because a row-local action must not destroy unrelated in-flight work.
|
||||
**Expose a protocol-only promotion operation.** Rejected because no product interaction reorders Queue. A public operation without a current consumer would add ordering semantics and tests for speculative use.
|
||||
|
||||
## Verification
|
||||
|
||||
AgentLoop contract tests hold prompt admission while editing, removing, and promoting exact occurrences, then verify the resulting independent-turn order and terminal lifecycle events. Host schema and proxy tests cover authoritative snapshots, reconnect, typed not-found errors, and the RPC transport. Client runtime and QueueDock tests cover non-optimistic projection, queued-only Web projection, text-only editing, save and cancel affordances, removal, retirement races, disabled mixed-content editing, and the absent send-now control. Keyless browser scenarios drive the exposed edit and delete actions and keep accepted pending steering hidden until it becomes a durable transcript event through the built Web composition and real HTTP/SSE wire.
|
||||
AgentLoop contract tests hold prompt admission while editing and removing exact queued occurrences, reject mutations of steering occurrences, and verify the resulting independent turn and terminal lifecycle events. Host schema and proxy tests cover queued-only authoritative snapshots, reconnect, typed not-found errors, and the RPC transport. Client runtime and QueueDock tests cover non-optimistic projection, text-only editing, save and cancel affordances, removal, retirement races, and disabled mixed-content editing. Keyless browser scenarios drive the exposed edit and delete actions through the built Web composition and real HTTP/SSE wire.
|
||||
|
||||
## Consequences
|
||||
|
||||
Pending work gains precise row operations without becoming durable session history. Occurrence identity is a live process-local capability and disappears at claim, cancellation, disposal, or restart; reconnect recovers only items still held by the live Agent. Send-now is intentionally weaker than interruption, and editing intentionally excludes mixed content until an editor can preserve every block.
|
||||
Queued work gains precise row operations without becoming durable session history. Occurrence identity is a live process-local capability and disappears at claim, cancellation, disposal, or restart; reconnect recovers only queued items still held by the live Agent. Editing excludes mixed content until an editor can preserve every block, while pending steering remains outside this operation surface.
|
||||
|
||||
The protocol now carries full queue snapshots on each change. Queues are expected to remain short, so deterministic recovery and multi-client convergence are preferred over an incremental mutation protocol.
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
|
||||
# Agent Note(agent 决策记录):为待处理队列项提供编辑、移除与前移操作
|
||||
# Agent Note(agent 决策记录):为待处理队列项提供编辑与移除操作
|
||||
|
||||
Status: implemented
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -6,19 +6,17 @@ Status: implemented
|
||||
|
||||
## 问题
|
||||
|
||||
Web 队列能够渲染待处理消息,但无法操作其中某一行。`MessageId` 不足以充当寻址标识,因为调用方可以多次将同一条不可变消息加入队列。浏览器还会根据轮次和状态事件推断队列项已退役,因此当行操作与驱动器认领发生竞态时,系统无法给出权威结果。
|
||||
|
||||
“立即发送”还引入了另一项语义选择:它可以表示重新排序下一个独立轮次、以 steering(中途引导)方式打断当前轮次,或取消当前工作。只有第一种解释能够保留该队列行原有的投递契约。
|
||||
Web 队列能够渲染待处理消息,但无法编辑或删除其中某一行。`MessageId` 不足以充当寻址标识,因为调用方可以多次将同一条不可变消息加入队列。浏览器还会根据轮次和状态事件推断队列项已退役,因此当行操作与驱动器认领发生竞态时,系统无法给出权威结果。
|
||||
|
||||
## 决策
|
||||
|
||||
**每次获准进入 FIFO 的项都有独立标识。** AgentLoop 会铸造不透明的 `InboxItemId`,并发布一个 `InboxItem`,其中包含该 id、已有标识的 `UserMessage`,以及接受时确定的 `queued | steering` 放置方式。复用同一个 `MessageId` 会创建不同的 inbox 标识。注入绕过 FIFO,因此不会获得 inbox 标识。
|
||||
|
||||
**变更边界止于驱动器认领。** `Agent.updateInbox(id, action)` 会同步搜索仍处于待处理状态的 queued 和 steering FIFO。编辑会替换已冻结的内容,同时保留 `InboxItemId`、`MessageId`、来源、放置方式、唤醒策略和位置。移除会发出该次入队项的终态 discard。前移会把它移至当前 FIFO 的队首;普通 queued 项还会变为可唤醒。驱动器会在提示词接纳或排空 steering 之前移除该项,因此之后的变更会返回 `not-found`,绝不会改写持久历史。
|
||||
**变更边界止于驱动器认领。** `Agent.updateInbox(id, action)` 会同步搜索待处理的 queued FIFO。编辑会替换已冻结的内容,同时保留 `InboxItemId`、`MessageId`、来源、唤醒策略和位置。移除会发出该次入队项的终态 discard。steering(中途引导)项和已被驱动器认领的项会返回 `not-found`,因此队列操作绝不会改写活动轮次输入或持久历史。
|
||||
|
||||
**实时账本是权威状态。** `agent/inbox/enqueue`、`update`、`dequeue` 和 `discard` 共同维护 Host 镜像。协议发送完整的 `session/queue` 快照,而非增量猜测。重连会发送当前基线,每次实时变更或终态事件都会整体替换它。客户端不会进行乐观编辑,也绝不根据 `turn/start`、`steering/message` 或状态变化退役队列行。
|
||||
**实时账本是权威状态。** `agent/inbox/enqueue`、`update`、`dequeue` 和 `discard` 共同维护 queued 入队项的 Host 镜像。协议发送完整的 `session/queue` 快照,而非增量猜测。重连会发送当前基线,每次 queued 变更或终态事件都会整体替换它。客户端不会进行乐观编辑,也绝不根据持久轮次事件或状态变化退役队列行。
|
||||
|
||||
**Web 操作保持投递类型。** QueueDock 只投影 `queued` 入队项;待处理的 `steering` 入队项仍保留在权威快照中,等待 Web 提供专用交互。它只暴露编辑和删除,不提供立即发送控件。仅当所有内容块都是文本时才提供编辑功能;编辑器不能静默丢弃非文本块。编辑中的行只展示保存和取消操作,对应的键盘操作分别是 Enter 和 Escape。删除会移除对应的精确入队项。协议层仍保留前移操作,但不会把它呈现为 Web 交互;该操作绝不会把 queued 工作转换为 steering,也不会取消活动工作。
|
||||
**Web 操作只面向 Queue。** Host 从 `session/queue` 中排除待处理 steering;steering 消费后仍沿用既有的持久 transcript(文本记录)路径。QueueDock 暴露编辑和删除,不提供立即发送控件。仅当所有内容块都是文本时才提供编辑功能;编辑器不能静默丢弃非文本块。编辑中的行只展示保存和取消操作,对应的键盘操作分别是 Enter 和 Escape。删除会移除对应的精确入队项。
|
||||
|
||||
## 考虑过的替代方案
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -26,16 +24,16 @@ Web 队列能够渲染待处理消息,但无法操作其中某一行。`Messag
|
||||
|
||||
**在浏览器中进行乐观变更。** 不予采纳,因为驱动器认领或另一个客户端可能先于 Host 操作完成。等待权威快照可以显式呈现所有权边界,并让 `queue-item-not-found` 报告真实竞态。
|
||||
|
||||
**把立即发送视为 steering。** 不予采纳,因为这会把一个独立的排队轮次变成当前轮次的上下文,绕过普通提示词接纳,并改变单次 send 单轮次保证。前移只改变优先级,不改变投递语义。
|
||||
**将待处理 steering 纳入队列变更协议。** 不予采纳,因为 QueueDock 没有 steering 交互,而编辑或删除活动轮次输入会把此功能扩展到当前消费方之外。应由专用 steering 交互负责该投递契约。
|
||||
|
||||
**前移前取消活动轮次。** 不予采纳,因为仅影响某一行的操作不应破坏无关的进行中工作。
|
||||
**暴露仅协议层的前移操作。** 不予采纳,因为当前没有产品交互会重新排序 Queue。公开一个没有当前消费方的操作,会为了推测性用途引入排序语义和测试。
|
||||
|
||||
## 验证
|
||||
|
||||
AgentLoop 契约测试会在编辑、移除和前移对应的精确入队项时阻塞提示词接纳,随后验证所得独立轮次顺序及终态生命周期事件。Host schema 与代理测试覆盖权威快照、重连、类型化 not-found 错误和 RPC 传输。客户端运行时和 QueueDock 测试覆盖非乐观投影、Web 仅投影 queued 项、仅文本编辑、保存与取消入口、移除、退役竞态、禁用混合内容编辑,以及不提供立即发送控件。无密钥浏览器场景会通过构建后的 Web 组合和真实 HTTP/SSE 协议操作公开的编辑和删除,并使已接受的待处理 steering 在成为持久 transcript(文本记录)事件之前保持隐藏。
|
||||
AgentLoop 契约测试会在编辑和移除精确 queued 入队项时阻塞提示词接纳,拒绝对 steering 入队项的变更,并验证所得独立轮次及终态生命周期事件。Host schema 与代理测试覆盖仅含 queued 项的权威快照、重连、类型化 not-found 错误和 RPC 传输。客户端运行时和 QueueDock 测试覆盖非乐观投影、仅文本编辑、保存与取消入口、移除、退役竞态,以及禁用混合内容编辑。无密钥浏览器场景会通过构建后的 Web 组合和真实 HTTP/SSE 协议操作公开的编辑和删除。
|
||||
|
||||
## 后果
|
||||
|
||||
待处理工作获得精确的行操作,但不会因此成为持久会话历史。单次入队标识是进程本地的实时寻址凭据,会在认领、取消、dispose 或重启时消失;重连只能恢复仍由活跃 Agent 持有的项。立即发送有意弱于打断,而编辑也有意排除混合内容,直至编辑器能够保留每个块。
|
||||
queued 工作获得精确的行操作,但不会因此成为持久会话历史。单次入队标识是进程本地的实时寻址凭据,会在认领、取消、dispose 或重启时消失;重连只能恢复仍由活跃 Agent 持有的 queued 项。编辑会排除混合内容,直至编辑器能够保留每个块;待处理 steering 则不属于此操作接口。
|
||||
|
||||
现在,协议会在每次变更时携带完整队列快照。队列预期保持较短,因此系统优先选择确定性恢复和多客户端收敛,而非增量变更协议。
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user