# Message Feedback

English | [中文](feedback.zh.md)

[`@deepseek-ai/dsh-message-feedback`](../../packages/feedback/message-feedback) owns editable feedback for individual assistant messages. It is deliberately separate from the immutable Session-level `feedback/record` event: message feedback is a local storage-domain sidecar, not Session-log content or a projection, and it performs no telemetry handoff.

Source: [`packages/feedback/message-feedback/src/types.ts`](../../packages/feedback/message-feedback/src/types.ts)

## Public types

```ts type-equiv
/** Opaque compare-and-set token for one exact feedback item revision. */
type MessageFeedbackVersion = Branded<'MessageFeedbackVersion'>
```

```ts type-equiv
/** The human's overall judgment of one assistant message. */
type MessageFeedbackRating = 'positive' | 'negative'
```

```ts type-equiv
/** One current feedback value and its opaque mutation token. */
interface MessageFeedbackItem {
  /** Stable identity of the assistant message inside the owning Session. */
  readonly messageId: MessageId
  /** Overall positive or negative judgment. */
  readonly rating: MessageFeedbackRating
  /** Optional explanation, preserved verbatim after validation. */
  readonly note?: string
  /** Equality-only token replaced by every material create or update. */
  readonly version: MessageFeedbackVersion
  /** Host-assigned creation time in Unix epoch milliseconds. */
  readonly createdAt: number
  /** Host-assigned time of the most recent material update. */
  readonly updatedAt: number
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Read all message feedback belonging to one persisted Session lifecycle. */
interface MessageFeedbackListRequest {
  /** Persisted Session whose sidecar should be read. */
  readonly sessionId: SessionId
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Current feedback values for one Session, in first-creation order. */
interface MessageFeedbackListValue {
  /** Fresh immutable item snapshots. */
  readonly items: readonly MessageFeedbackItem[]
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Create or replace feedback for one assistant message. */
interface MessageFeedbackPutRequest {
  /** Persisted Session that owns the target message. */
  readonly sessionId: SessionId
  /** Target assistant-message identity. */
  readonly messageId: MessageId
  /** Desired overall judgment. */
  readonly rating: MessageFeedbackRating
  /** Optional non-blank explanation. */
  readonly note?: string
  /** Observed item version, or `null` to require that no item exists. */
  readonly ifVersion: MessageFeedbackVersion | null
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Delete feedback for one message after observing its current version. */
interface MessageFeedbackDeleteRequest {
  /** Persisted Session that owns the sidecar. */
  readonly sessionId: SessionId
  /** Message whose feedback should be absent after this operation. */
  readonly messageId: MessageId
  /** Observed item version; ignored when the item is already absent. */
  readonly ifVersion: MessageFeedbackVersion
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Idempotent deletion acknowledgement. */
interface MessageFeedbackDeleteValue {
  /** Stable postcondition shared by the first deletion and every retry. */
  readonly absent: true
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** No persisted Session header exists for the requested id. */
interface MessageFeedbackSessionNotFound {
  readonly code: 'session-not-found'
  readonly sessionId: SessionId
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** The id does not name a derived, append-origin assistant message. */
interface MessageFeedbackTargetNotFound {
  readonly code: 'target-not-found'
  readonly sessionId: SessionId
  readonly messageId: MessageId
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** A material mutation did not match the addressed item's current version. */
interface MessageFeedbackVersionConflict {
  readonly code: 'version-conflict'
  /** Authoritative current item, or `null` when it does not exist. */
  readonly current: MessageFeedbackItem | null
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** A supplied note contains no non-whitespace character. */
interface MessageFeedbackNoteBlank {
  readonly code: 'note-blank'
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** A supplied note exceeds the configured UTF-8 byte limit. */
interface MessageFeedbackNoteTooLarge {
  readonly code: 'note-too-large'
  readonly maxBytes: number
  readonly actualBytes: number
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Failures shared by the public message-feedback operations. */
type MessageFeedbackFailure =
  | MessageFeedbackSessionNotFound
  | MessageFeedbackTargetNotFound
  | MessageFeedbackVersionConflict
  | MessageFeedbackNoteBlank
  | MessageFeedbackNoteTooLarge
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Successful public operation result. */
interface MessageFeedbackSuccess<T> {
  readonly ok: true
  readonly value: T
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Rejected public operation result with a stable business failure. */
interface MessageFeedbackRejected<E extends MessageFeedbackFailure> {
  readonly ok: false
  readonly error: E
}
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Result returned by the message-feedback `list` operation. */
type MessageFeedbackListResult =
  | MessageFeedbackSuccess<MessageFeedbackListValue>
  | MessageFeedbackRejected<MessageFeedbackSessionNotFound>
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Result returned by the message-feedback `put` operation. */
type MessageFeedbackPutResult =
  | MessageFeedbackSuccess<MessageFeedbackItem>
  | MessageFeedbackRejected<
    | MessageFeedbackSessionNotFound
    | MessageFeedbackTargetNotFound
    | MessageFeedbackVersionConflict
    | MessageFeedbackNoteBlank
    | MessageFeedbackNoteTooLarge
  >
```

```ts type-equiv
/** Result returned by the message-feedback `delete` operation. */
type MessageFeedbackDeleteResult =
  | MessageFeedbackSuccess<MessageFeedbackDeleteValue>
  | MessageFeedbackRejected<MessageFeedbackSessionNotFound | MessageFeedbackVersionConflict>
```

## Data and concurrency

One Session sidecar row contains its header identity `{createdAt, cwd}` and feedback items keyed by `MessageId`. Each item carries a positive or negative rating, an optional note, Host-assigned `createdAt`/`updatedAt` timestamps, and its own opaque version. Versions are compared only for equality and only against the addressed message; callers do not order or synthesize them.

`put` uses strict optimistic concurrency: every request for an existing item must match its current `ifVersion`, including a no-op. A conflict returns the authoritative current item (or `null`), so a caller can reconcile a lost response or a concurrent edit without another read. Deleting an already absent item succeeds. A per-Session queue encloses inspection, read, conflict evaluation, and whole-row write, so these guarantees cover concurrent calls in one Host process.

## Target and lifecycle authority

`SessionPersistence.inspect()` supplies the target Session observation without publishing or resuming an Agent and without committing cold repair. A cold `listSnapshots()` preflight classifies definite absence; inspection failure for a catalogued Session propagates as infrastructure failure. `put` accepts only a non-empty, append-origin `assistant/message` with the requested `MessageId`; replacement-origin, usage-only empty, and non-assistant records are not feedback targets.

The stored `{createdAt, cwd}` identity must match the inspected header. A mismatch is treated as absence: `list` returns no items, while `put` may replace the stale row with one bound to the current header identity. Forks use a new Session identity and receive no sidecar copy even when their seed contains the same messages.

## Persistence and Remote contract

The service stores whole Session rows in the `message_feedback` storage domain through `ctx.storageDomain`. Before `put` commits a row that references a target message, a matching live target passes through the canonical `ctx.sessions.flush` checkpoint; both live and cold paths are then physically read from sequence zero through `SessionPersistence.readFrom`. The resulting observation is revalidated before the sidecar write, so the durable target log always precedes its sidecar commit. `maxNoteBytes` is required and bounds note text by UTF-8 bytes; the Web Host composition sets `8192`. The package publishes the Host `messageFeedback.list`, `messageFeedback.put`, and `messageFeedback.delete` unary Remote contract through `GatewayService` and `@Remote`; the generated Cordis API below is the method-level authority.

Plugin disposal closes mutation admission, drains accepted per-Session queue work, and then closes the storage domain.

## Web surface

[`@deepseek-ai/dsh-client-ui-feedback`](../../packages/client/ui-feedback) is the browser consumer. `@deepseek-ai/dsh-api-remotes` mounts the generated `messageFeedback` contribution, so the plugin calls `ctx.remote.messageFeedback` and never touches the transport.

The controls are the `feedback` entry (order 10) of the `conversation.chat.assistant-actions` list slot, which `ui-conversation` declares and renders inside the finalized assistant message's IconActions row. Reaching that render site required one plumbing change: `AssistantMessageNode` now carries the optional `messageId` from the `assistant/message` event. The field is absent on interruption-frozen partials, and the render site skips the slot when it is absent, so only messages the Host accepts as feedback targets present controls.

One `FeedbackController` per Session backs every message control in that Session: a single `list` read seeds the whole transcript, deferred to first hover or focus rather than fired on mount. Each mutation sends the version that controller last observed as `ifVersion`; a `version-conflict` reply carries the authoritative item, so the controller reconciles from the reply instead of refetching. Mutations serialize per Session so a queued operation compares against the committed version. A `connection/reset` refreshes only Sessions already read.

## Boundaries and limitations

- The mutation queue is process-local. Storage-domain has no cross-process conditional write, so multiple Host writers to one storage root have no compare-and-swap or lost-update guarantee.
- Session persistence has no durable deletion API. The service does not treat `session/disposed` or `host/session-removed` as deletion and therefore performs no fake cascade; orphan sidecar rows may remain after out-of-band log removal.
- A request in the narrow interval after live detach but before the persistence catalog materializes the header can receive `session-not-found`; callers retry after retirement materialization.
- Cold requests scan the complete Session snapshot catalog because persistence has no lookup-by-id metadata operation. One Session row also has no item-count or aggregate-byte cap; `maxNoteBytes` bounds only each note until a concrete consumer owns a row policy.
- Header identity detects a reused id only when `{createdAt, cwd}` differs; a cloned log retaining the same header identity is indistinguishable by this contract.
- The Host contract records no authenticated actor or audit identity and therefore assumes a trusted caller boundary.
- The Web controls appear in the chat view only. The trajectory and waterfall views render no feedback entry even though their assistant nodes carry the same `messageId`.
- The sidecar publishes no live frames, so a second tab's rating becomes visible on reconnect or on the next conflict reply rather than immediately.
- The note editor does not pre-check `maxNoteBytes`; an oversized note fails on save with `note-too-large` rather than while typing.

<!-- BEGIN GENERATED cordis-surface (gen-cordis-catalog.ts) — do not edit between markers -->

<a id="cordis-surface"></a>

## Cordis API

Generated from source by `scripts/gen-cordis-catalog.ts` (verified fresh by `pnpm run verify-cordis-catalog` in doc-sync; regenerate with `pnpm run gen-cordis-catalog`) — this section is byte-identical in both language sides of the page. Signature blocks use a `ts cordis-catalog` fence and keep the original source JSDoc; dispatch modes are defined in the [primer](../cordis-primer.md#dispatch-modes), and the framework-inherited `ctx` API lives in [cordis-api/inherited.md](../cordis-api/inherited.md).

<a id="ctxmessagefeedback--messagefeedbackservice"></a>

### `ctx.messageFeedback` — `MessageFeedbackService`

Storage-domain sidecar service. It inspects persisted Session history and never creates or resumes an Agent or Session.

```ts cordis-catalog
/**
 * Read feedback belonging to the current persisted Session lifecycle.
 * A stale row from a reused Session id is invisible.
 * @param request - Session identity to inspect and list.
 * @returns current immutable items or `session-not-found`.
 */
@Remote('list') async list(request: MessageFeedbackListRequest): Promise<MessageFeedbackListResult>

/**
 * Create or replace feedback for one derived append-origin assistant
 * message. Every request must match the addressed item's current version;
 * a matching no-op returns the stored item without changing its revision.
 * @param request - target, desired value, and observed item version.
 * @returns the committed item or an explicit business failure.
 */
@Remote('put') put(request: MessageFeedbackPutRequest): Promise<MessageFeedbackPutResult>

/**
 * Delete one feedback item. Absence is successful regardless of the
 * supplied version; an existing item requires an exact version match.
 * @param request - Session, message, and observed item version.
 * @returns the stable absent postcondition, or an explicit failure.
 */
@Remote('delete') delete(request: MessageFeedbackDeleteRequest): Promise<MessageFeedbackDeleteResult>
```

Source: [`packages/feedback/message-feedback/src/index.ts:150`](../../packages/feedback/message-feedback/src/index.ts)
<!-- END GENERATED cordis-surface -->
